So a cab driver beat Guerrero, what does that say about Thurman and DSGs best win?

[Boxfan83]

Garcia still has the best win with Amir Khan.

forgot about Khan BUT Guerrero is by far his best WW win. Hell Guerrero would be Khans best WW win.

[DreamerUSA]

Thurman put Guerrero down so did Peralta. DSG won a close decision so did Peralta. What does that say about the WW division? Do you think its overrated??

Well like others have said. Robert is'nt either of their best win. I guess you can say its Danny's best win at WW, but technicaly Peterson was fought at WW, so no. Overall I would'nt even rank Guerrero in Danny's top 5 wins.

Thurman has Chavez and Porter and I think the Zaveck, Soto-Karass and Quintana(even though it was at 154) wins are on par or close with Guerrero. Yes Guerrero has the better accomplishments, but he is'nt a better fighter than those I mentioned imo.

[12TRIBEsRiSe]

how is that Thurman n Garcias best wins?

[M Bison]

forgot about Khan BUT Guerrero is by far his best WW win. Hell Guerrero would be Khans best WW win.

Well Collazo is still a good win to a degree
Devon Alexander lost to a guy who was a massive underdog but he wasn't fighting no damn cab driver lmfao!

[Boxfan83]

Well like others have said. Robert is'nt either of their best win. I guess you can say its Danny's best win at WW, but technicaly Peterson was fought at WW, so no. Overall I would'nt even rank Guerrero in Danny's top 5 wins.

Thurman has Chavez and Porter and I think the Zaveck, Soto-Karass and Quintana(even though it was at 154) wins are on par or close with Guerrero. Yes Guerrero has the better accomplishments, but he is'nt a better fighter than those I mentioned imo.

Peterson imo has never been that good and his career is def in question with all those steroids he likes to do.

Chavez & soto karass are fringe gate keepers at best. Zaveck lol! At least Guerrero is what a 3 division champ and 1x ww Interim champ?

how is that Thurman n Garcias best wins?

Its funny now that Guerrero loses to a cab driver he falls down on their list. Lets face it, the WW division on the PBC side is OVERRATED except for maybe Spence but hes still getting his feet wet.

[Boxfan83]

Well Collazo is still a good win to a degree
Devon Alexander lost to a guy who was a massive underdog but he wasn't fighting no damn cab driver lmfao!

Devon Alexander lost to the guy Guerrero beat lol! Collazo ok, but I still think Guerrero is a better overall.

But its funny when you have to bring up guys like: Luis Collazo, Soto karass, Zaveck, PEDerson, etc as the best win , thats saying ALOT!!

[Szef]

Care to explain who is and where you would rank Guerrero in their win column?

Well, for Garcia it's either Khan or Matthysse. That's not even up for debate. And don't give me that BS that Lucas was never a world champion and Guerrero was. Yes it's true, but Matthysse was one of the hottest name in the game at the time he fought Swift and was expected to beat him on the Floyd - Canelo undercard and then fight Floyd.

Guerrero is a good name to have on your resume but let's not pretend that the reason why he's been somehow relevant in the recent years is the fact that he got thoroughly outboxed and outclassed by Floyd. But who hasn't?

As for Thurman, it's clearly Porter who's still a top guy in the division, and Guerrero is not.

Robert Guerrero has been shot for quite some time now and struggled in almost every post Floyd fight. He even struggled with guys he should've beaten with ease like Martinez for example.

[DreamerUSA]

Peterson imo has never been that good and his career is def in question with all those steroids he likes to do.

Chavez & soto karass are fringe gate keepers at best. Zaveck lol! At least Guerrero is what a 3 division champ and 1x ww Interim champ?



Its funny now that Guerrero loses to a cab driver he falls down on their list. Lets face it, the WW division on the PBC side is OVERRATED except for maybe Spence but hes still getting his feet wet.

Like I said accomplishment wise he looks better on the resume, but actually look at his career, who he fought for his titles. Its nothing impressive. Chavez would beat the **** out of the same competition. Karass beat Berto who is arguably Guerrero's best win and as for Zaveck. He is a former champion with several title defenses. So Guerrero gets props for good matchmaking to get his titles but you lol at Zaveck?

[12TRIBEsRiSe]

Peterson imo has never been that good and his career is def in question with all those steroids he likes to do.

Chavez & soto karass are fringe gate keepers at best. Zaveck lol! At least Guerrero is what a 3 division champ and 1x ww Interim champ?



Its funny now that Guerrero loses to a cab driver he falls down on their list. Lets face it, the WW division on the PBC side is OVERRATED except for maybe Spence but hes still getting his feet wet.

oh u meant at WW, DSG best wins are at 140, thurmans best win is porter at WW

[Boxfan83]

Like I said accomplishment wise he looks better on the resume, but actually look at his career, who he fought for his titles. Its nothing impressive. Chavez would beat the **** out of the same competition. Karass beat Berto who is arguably Guerrero's best win and as for Zaveck. He is a former champion with several title defenses. So Guerrero gets props for good matchmaking to get his titles but you lol at Zaveck?

Trust me I lol at Guerrero too. Chavez was neck and neck with Bam Bam Rios so that should say a lot, he was up by 1rd in a fight where Rios was gaining some momentum so I doubt Chavez even beats Berto. And for anyone to bring up Karass as a best win that shows their resume is complete and utter doo doo. I will give it to Danny that he has Khan and Mattysse BUT I think its safe to say Guerrero has a punchers chance against Khan, anyone does really and Mattysse vs. Guerrero wouldve been similar to Guerrero vs. Aldin.