Hopkins or Toney - who was better?

[Derranged]

Little Coward Chicken Girl Golovkin would've ducked them both. Biggest joke in boxing history.

[IronDanHamza]

definitely not, stopping a welterweight in a middleweight bout isn't some sort of out of this world type event.

hopkins has never been engaged in an enthralling fight, at least not any that i can remember.

i mean even toney's fight with holyfield .. i've always enjoyed james toney's fight style.

He'd stopped a Welterweight that moved to MW and proved himself as a MW.

Do you not rate Hagler's win over Hearns either?

Hopkins schooling and stopping Tito was a better performance than any of Toney's performance.

Toney doesn't have a dominant performance over a top fighter.

[IronDanHamza]

Still doesn't detract from the fact that James went from 160 to HW and got the KO over an ATG there...

The corpse of an ATG.

[IronDanHamza]

Lol.

Sounds to me like YDKSAB...

So you're actually trying to tell me that James Toney has a high ring IQ?

[IronDanHamza]

LOL what difference does it make? And better at what? The man said it himself.
Roy Jones was asked who was the best guy he fought in his prime and he immediately said James Toney. You can also find that video on youtube.

It makes a huge difference. It's an entirely different statment.

[Nay_Sayer]

Hopkins schooling and stopping Tito was a better performance than any of Toney's performance.

Now I'm convinced that YDKSAB.

The come from behind KO of Michael Nunn was a thing of beauty - as was his outclassing Jirov..

[Nay_Sayer]

So you're actually trying to tell me that James Toney has a high ring IQ?

It's painfully obvious that he does to ANYONE who has a clue about the sport of boxing. I can't believe this is even a question. Sorry son but if you think James Toney doesn't have a HIGH ring IQ then YDKSAB...

[12TRIBEsRiSe]

James toney is my fav fighter ever but Hopkins worked harder Ill give it to him

[baya]

He'd stopped a Welterweight that moved to MW and proved himself as a MW.

Do you not rate Hagler's win over Hearns either?

Hopkins schooling and stopping Tito was a better performance than any of Toney's performance.

Toney doesn't have a dominant performance over a top fighter.

toney taking out nunn is better than hops taking out tito.

[baya]

So you're actually trying to tell me that James Toney has a high ring IQ?

james toney has a very high ring IQ.