Where do you place Brook p4p with GGG win?

[tiois85]

The biggest proudest moment of brooks career is because of Amir khan, he literally cannot escape Khan's shadow. Khan motivated him to commit suicide, so sad.

Ggg has made legit middleweights utterly crumble and submit, the fight is a joke and Brook is a willing lamb to the slaughter deserves no support.

[New England]

This is what the AtG list looks like right now:

1. Golovkin
2. Marciano
3. Duran
4. Greb
5. Dempsey
6. Pep
7. Benny Leonard
8. Klitschko
9. Mickey Walker
10. Fitzsimmons

It'll be a TOUGH task jumping over so many names but the odds are in his favor. Gennady took the risk of fighting the undefeated Brook in his hometown, he WILL HAVE TO KO, otherwise, Brook will win by decision. He boxes better than floyd and hes bigger.

you're missing a few blacks.

[Joe Beamish]

Not sure where Brook would be ranked. But Floyd would be so jealous.

[Boxing lives]

please name these "6 of the top 10 MWs" that Golovkin has beat.

Peter Quillin has Daniel Jacobs, Andy Lee, Fernando Guerrero and Hassan N'Dam all on his hit list. Daniel Jacobs' resume is thinner, but even he has Quillin, Mora, and Pirog on his ledger.

Daniel Geale, Martin Murray, and David Lemieux, but who else is really in that conversation?

Haha Jacobs has the ugly KO loss to Pirog on his ledger. Your using that to build up his resume? He is the one top ranked fighter in the division who has a crappier resume then GGG. Proksa was probably a top ten rated win as well. Its too bad Pirog/GGG never happened. It would have been a war.

[SeekDaGreat]

How can you put him top ten when you have Danny Garcia and Bradley that have cleaned out divisions and aren't o the list then Kell Brook gets two notable wins and jumps up to P4P#1?

The meth you guys smoke, must be highly concentrated and very dangerous to the growth of your brains. I would advise to stop smoking it.

[SeekDaGreat]

Terrence Crawford is on the list too

Hes never even fought a champion, has he?

Who the **** makes these lists. A group of casuals who can't see when someone is being groomed for hopefully bigger and better things? You should get on the list when you do big things, not when you're coming up fighting b list fighters. Jesus H Christ...

[mathed]

Golovkin has yet to show anyone how good he actually is (blowing out C level fighters doesn't tell me much; beyond that, you can't point to a single person that Golovkin has fought who Daniel Jacobs, Peter Quillin, and possibly Billy Joe Saunders/Chris Eubank Jr/Andy Lee couldn't beat).

If Brook steps in and boxes Golovkin's ears off to a wide decision, people will look to who Golovkin had spent the last 4-6 years fighting, acknowledge that the comp was bunk, and Golovkin would be seen as a hype job.

Lemiuex would KO Jacobs, Eubank jr and Lee. I think Monroe Jr would give all those guys major problems as well.

GGG fought TONS of elite amateurs and pretty much dominated all of them. Now he is doing the exact same thing as a pro. I think that you'll find there is a reason why guys don't want to face him. He trains like an animal and can change gears. It may be a case where he is making pretty good boxers look like they are rubbish because he is more than the robotic brawler that people label him as sometimes.

[TheCell8]

1 or 2, comfortably.

[daggum]

brook's going to go in there and clinch his way to the p4p number 1 slot

[Tails]

If by some miracle Brook beat GGG, he would easily be pfp #1. There are a handful of people in boxing right now that if you beat them would be considered A level victories. Starting from the lower weights to the higher ones it goes Gonzalez, Rigondeaux, Santa Cruz, Lomachenko/Walters, Golovkin, Ward, and Kovalev. These are guys that even though they haven't fought everyone in there weight class due to various reasons, they have set themselves apart from the rest by the fashion in which they beat similar level of opposition. I may have left out some people but you get the gist of it.

Now in the case of Brook going up two divisions it would be considered a legendary win because he defeated an A level opponent in his prime two divisions north. For comparison sake on the quality of a win over Golovkin, if the Canelo-Golovkin fight happened and Canelo was to win that fight it would be considered Canelo's best win on his resume by far at this current moment in time.