Is Trout vs Brook a mismatch?

[MASTERBX]

Instead of admitting lil g is a coward, you do all types of mental gymnastics to justify his foolishness.

[Eastcoast]

In second of half of his fight with one of the Charlo twins he boxed extremely well.

I think that speaks to the degree of Jermall's own inexperience/limitations. Jermall's 26 and that was by far his biggest step up.

Trout still has good ability, but I think he's far removed from the guy who outboxed Cotto. He was taken apart by Lara, which how I'd see a Trout/Brook fight going. I think Kell hits harder and has faster hands/reflexes, and as fast feet.

[FrankieBruno]

Not a mismatch

but Brook would lose...

[_Maxi]

Maxi Pad, you suck. Maxi Pad, your logic sucks.

Trout vs Brook wouldn't be a a mismatch. They're both about the same height and only ONE weigh division apart. It's not inconceivable or un-natural for a champion fighter to jump up ONE division and fight a guy on the downside of his career. Infact, it's happened many, many times.

Same could be said about Canelo, jumping up ONE division to fight at 154 or at Caneloweight, ONE division +1 pound. That's where the whole controversy is, whether Canelo is a Middleweight or not.

GGG, is different, he's TWO whole division higher. Fights at full 160.

Like everyone is saying, you suck and so does your logic.

Canelo fight night weight at 154 -> 172 (trout fight) -> FAIR FIGHT FOR BROOK
Golovkin fight night weight at 160 -> 171 (wade fight) -> UNFAIR FIGHT FOR BROOK.

And I'm the one with flawed logic. My god.

[LacedUp]

Not a mismatch

but Brook would lose...

This guy

Brook loses every fantasy fight.

#KhanIssues

[NaijaD]

Maxi Pad, you suck. Maxi Pad, your logic sucks.

Trout vs Brook wouldn't be a a mismatch. They're both about the same height and only ONE weigh division apart. It's not inconceivable or un-natural for a champion fighter to jump up ONE division and fight a guy on the downside of his career. Infact, it's happened many, many times.

Same could be said about Canelo, jumping up ONE division to fight at 154 or at Caneloweight, ONE division +1 pound. That's where the whole controversy is, whether Canelo is a Middleweight or not.

GGG, is different, he's TWO whole division higher. Fights at full 160.

Like everyone is saying, you suck and so does your logic.

What this guy said!!

We know your trying to dispel the idea that GGG-Brook is a pure unadulterated mismatch, why you're trying?? like most people I don't know.

Trout is not the same size as GGG, he's actually listed as the same height as Brook (5'9).... knowing you, you probably took Trouts heaviest fight night weight to prove this dumb argument.

Honestly the GGG fan base doesn't need people like you and Jubei doing stuff like this, have some integrity. Any unbiased fan can see the man is avoided by the 160 landscape but those guys should also see that GGG-Brook is a joke of a fight that team GGG should not have made.

[_Maxi]

What this guy said!!

We know your trying to dispel the idea that GGG-Brook is a pure unadulterated mismatch, why you're trying?? like most people I don't know.

Trout is not the same size as GGG, he's actually listed as the same height as Brook (5'9).... knowing you, you probably took Trouts heaviest fight night weight to prove this dumb argument.

Honestly the GGG fan base doesn't need people like you and Jubei doing stuff like this, have some integrity. Any unbiased fan can see the man is avoided by the 160 landscape but those guys should also see that GGG-Brook is a joke of a fight that team GGG should not have made.

GGG fight night weight = 171
Trout fight night weight = 171

[NaijaD]

GGG fight night weight = 171
Trout fight night weight = 171

For anyone reading this, please don't be fooled by Maxi.... He's taken Trouts highest fight night weight to push this ******ed thread. Trout was in the mid 160's against Charlo and looked much smaller than Jermall.

Maxi is the worst type of poster, he goes on these crusades against Floyd fan boys and the supposedly anti-white posters thinking he's this pillar of justice against bias.

He's as big a stan as they come..... GGG can do no wrong in his eyes, word of advice to everyone: If you never have any criticism of your favourite fighter then you are a biased fanboy.

[hhs661]

Of course not, Jo Jo Dan and Bizier has prepped him well for that division

[_Maxi]

For anyone reading this, please don't be fooled by Maxi.... He's taken Trouts highest fight night weight to push this ******ed thread. Trout was in the mid 160's against Charlo and looked much smaller than Jermall.

Maxi is the worst type of poster, he goes on these crusades against Floyd fan boys and the supposedly anti-white posters thinking he's this pillar of justice against bias.

He's as big a stan as they come..... GGG can do no wrong in his eyes, word of advice to everyone: If you never have any criticism of your favourite fighter then you are a biased fanboy.

Proof that Trout was in the mid 160's against Charlo?