Was Porter/Thurman the best Welterweight fight since Mosley/Oscar 1?

[The Viper]

Best in years imo.........but is it the best since then?

[Raonic]

Best since Manny/Marquez 4.

[R-C]

Floyd Vs Chino was really good too.

[soul_survivor]

Best in years imo.........but is it the best since then?

Mann/JMM IV
Manny/Cotto
Cotto/Marg I

Just off the top of my head, so no it wasn't.

But it was a terrific fight, one which falls just short of greatness but exceptional none the less.

[muslimer12]

Since Bradley-Provo

[gauze]

add paul williams vs margarito and david estrada vs kermit cintron to the list as well

[bojangles1987]

No way. Just in recent years Bradley/Provodnikov and Marquez/Pac 4 were clearly better.

[Idunnoshet]

Gotta go with Margarito vs Cotto 1 .

[Willy Wanker]

Great fight, but it's not the best Welterweight fight in the last 16 years. C'mon man, lol.

Besides the fights already mentioned in this thread, I think even Berto-Ortiz 1 was better.

But Thurman-Porter is probably the best since Floyd-Maidana 1. And then Pac-Marquez 4 before that.

[John Locke]

It's up there, some of my other favourites would be Cotto vs Margs, Pac vs Cotto, Margs vs Williams, Floyd vs Maidana 1, Mosley vs Forrest