Could a Prime "Lights Out" Clean Out current 160-175lb's?

[bojangles1987]

Toney brutalises GGG, Kovalev's tailor made for him and Stevenson gets brutally KO'd yet Toney can't even comfortably beat Dave Tiberi, Merqui Sosa, Sanderline Williams and the list goes on.

Toney is the greatest "fantasy" fighter of all time.

Yeah, it's easy to take the best Toney you've ever seen and pick him to beat all kinds of fighters, but he sure as hell wasn't that kind of fighter all the time.

[The Viper]

Man I can't believe you guys think GGG would Ice a prime toney and hearns with ease man.....what a group.....

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Toney brutalises GGG, Kovalev's tailor made for him and Stevenson gets brutally KO'd yet Toney can't even comfortably beat Dave Tibri, Merqui Sosa, Sanderline Williams and the list goes on.

Toney is the greatest "fantasy" fighter of all time.

Well toney fought to the level of competition... And the thread is prime toney...


Toney at his best, massacres ggg...

[IronDanHamza]

Well toney fought to the level of competition... And the thread is prime toney...


Toney at his best, massacres ggg...

No he didn't.

Toney was in his prime when Dave Tiberi comfortably beat him.

But of course in fantasy land where James Toney "massacres" top level fighters he somehow "massacres" GGG. What did James Toney do in his career to suggest he would do that? Who did James Toney "massacre"? Iran Barkely?

[IronDanHamza]

Yeah, it's easy to take the best Toney you've ever seen and pick him to beat all kinds of fighters, but he sure as hell wasn't that kind of fighter all the time.

"The best Toney you've ever seen" still can't do what these people say he can.

What is "the best Toney"? He only ever looked good against sub par fighters. And even against sub par fighters he didn't look good all the time.

In fantasy land he knocks out GGG, Kovalev and Stevenson in the same night in 1 round but in real life he loses comfortably to Dave Tiberi and Drake Thazdi, can't get clear decisions over Merqeui Sosa and Sanderline Williams, gets his ears boxed off by Reggie Johnson and loses close hard fought decisions to Montel Griffin.