WHO ??? came closest to beating FLOYD???

[SUBZER0ED]

Not sure why posters keep saying that fight was a robbery...if you watch it and score it round by round, yes it was a close fight...but how can Robbery be used?

That was Castillo's fight. Even with Drakulich's unfair taking a point from Jose for hitting on the break, while only warning Floyd for elbows and hitting after the bell, Castillo landed more punches. He should have won the decision.

[Zaroku]

That was Castillo's fight. Even with Drakulich's unfair taking a point from Jose for hitting on the break, while only warning Floyd for elbows and hitting after the bell, Castillo landed more punches. He should have won the decision.

Drac was too involved in that fight. It was a good scrap too. Maidana send the same mauling style. Floyd was uncomfortable in both fights.

[Zaroku]

i had Floyd edging out Manny by the slightest of margins...i think i had it 113.5-113 on my card

Hahahahahahaha thanks!!! I needed that!!

Great stuff.

[Doctor_Tenma]

That was Castillo's fight. Even with Drakulich's unfair taking a point from Jose for hitting on the break, while only warning Floyd for elbows and hitting after the bell, Castillo landed more punches. He should have won the decision.

Its been a while but didn't he deduct a point from Mayweather as well?

[Zaroku]

Its been a while but didn't he deduct a point from Mayweather as well?

Drac did that, I forgot what for, but he did. It was a close fight.

[Street]

Castillo no doubt about it.

The fight was so close, it could have been called a draw or scored for Castillo. Floyd knew this and that is why he gave Castillo the rematch.

[Zaroku]

Its been a while but didn't he deduct a point from Mayweather as well?

That was a great fight. Castillo was pounding the **** out of the body, compubox favored Castillo. On that night.... I lean towards Castillo.

[Zaroku]

Castillo no doubt about it.

The fight was so close, it could have been called a draw or scored for Castillo. Floyd knew this and that is why he gave Castillo the rematch.

I think so too. It was rare toe to toe Floyd, he was firing back too. Great fight.

This thread seems to indicate that other fighters didn't come close.
But, Maidana made it rough and tumble.

Mosley buckled his knees, but then Floyd adjusted.
DLH tried....
Cotto drew blood
In slow motion PAC ....

[Zaroku]

Castillo no doubt about it.

The fight was so close, it could have been called a draw or scored for Castillo. Floyd knew this and that is why he gave Castillo the rematch.

If I would have added Canelo as an option, do you think he would get more votes than De La Hoya, and others?

[Tago Nang Tago]

castillo done beat that ass clean. we know what happened.