Now the dust has settled on May 2 - Manny and PED accusations

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • sunny31
    Undisputed Champion
    Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
    • Feb 2006
    • 5780
    • 450
    • 35
    • 128,703

    #1

    Now the dust has settled on May 2 - Manny and PED accusations

    First off I feel Pacquiao has got a bad rap after the fight because a lot of people were building this fight to be a 50/50 which it never was. The shoulder injury thing I guess didn't help, but I would prefer to stick to boxing in this thread, and kind of defend Manny's performance and also address the black cloud that was put over him by the Mayweather's, Malignaggi, etc.

    What happened to the small weak fighter that would get knocked out as soon he was randomly tested? I could pull out a lot of interviews where the Mayweather's went on record to this tune. As well as many people on here. Regardless of the result Manny was CLEARLY the stronger fighter on the night and he hurt Floyd with less than full blooded shots. I am not saying that he never participated in PED use, I am not sure either way, but he certainly didn't look any different to what we have seen in the past, in fact to me anyway he looked a little sharper than he had recently if not the normal trend of decline we have been seeing since Margarito.

    There is no doubting Floyd clearly won and pretty much Willie Pepp'd Manny, his defence and skill was the difference which most educated fans predicted would happen. But Manny also showed great skills in the ring that night, and in fact you could argue that he landed the better, cleaner, and more damaging shots in the fight. He showed an aptitude at range and in a tactical boxing match with one of the greatest tactical boxers ever! Normally by the second half of a fight Floyd has dented his opponent and causes damage by sitting down on his shots and throwing some effective combinations, he never really got control of Manny in that way, that is real credit to Pacquiao because to be honest I expected him to start getting lit up by the 9th round.

    Just some conclusions in the fight that seem to have been overlooked:

    - Manny is an extremely underrated technician, he caused Floyd more technical problems then any of you would care to see that night.
    - Manny is not an aggressive volume pressure fighter, he throws volume when he is attacked or his opponent stands still. So why did everyone expect him to fight like Mike Tyson or Roberto Duran in Montreal?
    - Most people were disappointed with Manny's performance, I was not, I found some aspects of his performance extremely impressive.
    - The one thing I can criticise him for is not pressing enough in the latter part of the fight when it was clear he was down.
    - Ultimately I don't think the injury lost him the fight, I go back to my original thoughts in 2009, I thought Manny would push him and give him a tough night, but I never thought he could win (although after Cotto I wasn't so sure, that is when the fight should have happened).
    - I admire both of these guys and they are more suited to being 15 round fighters, I have never seen two fighters who retain their technique all the way through a 12 round fight, I think this has set them apart from every other fighter in their generation, in my head I question whether this is down to superior strength and conditioning or something else?

    Its time to give both guys credit - plus the misconception that the fight was a one sided rout is just not true. Manny showed his greatness in the ring that night, Floyd was just that chunk better. I think Floyd would have done that to many great fighters.
  • Nubia
    The Driver's Seat
    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
    • Jun 2015
    • 3374
    • 157
    • 100
    • 10,761

    #2
    Here, let me end this thread real quick.

    Comment

    • Outwest Exp 355
      Undisputed Champion
      Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
      • Nov 2012
      • 9760
      • 1,183
      • 921
      • 47,595

      #3
      To be honest Manny did better than I ever thought he would do. His movement definitely troubled Floyd at times during the fight.

      Comment

      • IMDAZED
        Fair but Firm
        Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
        • May 2006
        • 42644
        • 1,134
        • 1,770
        • 67,152

        #4
        Manny was competitive early -- you ask why he didn't press the attack knowing he was behind. One need look no further than the end of the sixth round. He was tiring, had landed good shots but it was clear Floyd wasn't going anywhere and he was getting countered a lot. If he had continued to expend himself at that rate he would've gotten stopped.

        Comment

        • sunny31
          Undisputed Champion
          Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
          • Feb 2006
          • 5780
          • 450
          • 35
          • 128,703

          #5
          Originally posted by IMDAZED
          Manny was competitive early -- you ask why he didn't press the attack knowing he was behind. One need look no further than the end of the sixth round. He was tiring, had landed good shots but it was clear Floyd wasn't going anywhere and he was getting countered a lot. If he had continued to expend himself at that rate he would've gotten stopped.
          I didn't really see that to be honest, I just think when he attacked Floyd when he was on the ropes, like most of everybody else he hit air, everything flew over the top. I think that stopped him more than anything else. There was counters but not so many. Most of Floyd's best punches for me were when he got off first with leads.

          He never looked to be struggling physically, I think part of his and Roach's strategy was to limit Floyd's counter opportunities, thus he wasn't quite as aggressive offensively, although Floyd always limits his opponents opportunities and makes them hesitant to throw because he does a good job of putting his body in positions to throw back.

          Comment

          • bigjavi973
            Undisputed Champion
            Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
            • Oct 2013
            • 24007
            • 759
            • 1,480
            • 1,236,071

            #6
            Originally posted by IMDAZED
            Manny was competitive early -- you ask why he didn't press the attack knowing he was behind. One need look no further than the end of the sixth round. He was tiring, had landed good shots but it was clear Floyd wasn't going anywhere and he was getting countered a lot. If he had continued to expend himself at that rate he would've gotten stopped.
            I actually disagree here.....

            1st round..... 1st right hand that mayweather lands and pac hesitates from that point on... even in the second round when floyd/pac clinched you can see it in his face.

            Comment

            • Lester Tutor
              Banned
              Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
              • May 2015
              • 17673
              • 365
              • 253
              • 22,224

              #7
              I don't know what's sadder, the lost hope from #48 or HBO's commentary and crickets after the 4th round with the Gatti bout. Ouch

              Comment

              • IMDAZED
                Fair but Firm
                Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                • May 2006
                • 42644
                • 1,134
                • 1,770
                • 67,152

                #8
                Originally posted by sunny31
                I didn't really see that to be honest, I just think when he attacked Floyd when he was on the ropes, like most of everybody else he hit air, everything flew over the top. I think that stopped him more than anything else. There was counters but not so many. Most of Floyd's best punches for me were when he got off first with leads.

                He never looked to be struggling physically, I think part of his and Roach's strategy was to limit Floyd's counter opportunities, thus he wasn't quite as aggressive offensively, although Floyd always limits his opponents opportunities and makes them hesitant to throw because he does a good job of putting his body in positions to throw back.
                I'm not sure I know what you mean by struggling physically. He was tired at the end of the sixth. I thought that much was clear. He kinda took rounds 7,8 and 9 off after that. I think he was hurt in the eighth too.

                Comment

                • IMDAZED
                  Fair but Firm
                  Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                  • May 2006
                  • 42644
                  • 1,134
                  • 1,770
                  • 67,152

                  #9
                  Originally posted by bigjavi973
                  I actually disagree here.....

                  1st round..... 1st right hand that mayweather lands and pac hesitates from that point on... even in the second round when floyd/pac clinched you can see it in his face.
                  I agree. But I think after the initial shock wore off, Manny resolved to fight back. Like in the fourth you could see he was pressing and in the sixth he went balls out (I actually think he hurt Floyd in the sixth). But I remember with about 20 seconds left in the sixth, Floyd landed several clean body and head shots that sorta backed him off...for good.

                  Comment

                  • soul_survivor
                    LOL @ Ali-Holmes
                    Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                    • Jun 2013
                    • 18949
                    • 623
                    • 473
                    • 65,236

                    #10
                    why's this fight being brought up again?

                    Also, if anything, its Mayweather and cheating we should be worried about.

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    TOP