Tyson Fury Says Porter Beat Brook...and Porters title was taken due to beef with GBP
Collapse
-
-
Comment
-
Brook won fairly clearly I thought, not sure why people are trying to doubt this.Last edited by BrometheusBob.; 10-30-2015, 02:11 PM.Comment
-
Jims card was fair, he was taking the home advantage in to account and the lack of action. It wasnt a clean cut type of fight, even Brooks owns stablemate and mentor had it a draw. While a lot of us had Brook winning, without bias, some people might take other things into consideration
If the fight were in the UK, Jims card would favor Brook.
What Jim didnt realize was Porter was having issues with GBP, and he wasnt going to walk away with that title, unless he KO'd Brook.
Brook did deserve the win, but it was a close fight, so not everyone is going to see eye to eye on the resultLast edited by FrankieBruno; 10-30-2015, 03:00 PM.Comment
-
Whoever thinks this was a close fight or even worse, that Porter won need to go watch another sport. Boxing is just not for u...Comment
-
Jims card was fair, he was taking the home advantage in to account and the lack of action. It wasnt a clean cut type of fight, even Brooks owns stablemate and mentor had it a draw. While a lot of us had Brook winning, without bias, some people might take other things into consideration
If the fight were in the UK, Jims card would favor Brook.
What Jim didnt realize was Porter was having issues with GBP, and he wasnt going to walk away with that title, unless he KO'd Brook.
Brook did deserve the win, but it was a close fight, so not everyone is going to see eye to eye on the result
Jim Watt scored Valuev the winner over Haye for the same reasons
Was that a fair scorecard, Frankie?Comment
-
but Jim aint a official judge, he's taking other things into account, and he wasnt the only one doing this.
Jim was judging Brook harder because of where the fight was at, who is was against and what he was seeing in the fight.it's not an ideal way of judging a fight, but we cant single out Jim for judging in this wayComment
-
Ofcourse thats not how you score a fight
but Jim aint a official judge, he's taking other things into account, and he wasnt the only one doing this.
Jim was judging Brook harder because of where the fight was at, who is was against and what he was seeing in the fight.it's not an ideal way of judging a fight, but we cant single out Jim for judging in this way
Lederman is a **** judge too but at least he scores it how he sees it. He doesn't say "OK JIM! Lemme tell you somethin.... I thought Brook clearly won that round with clean punches but we're in America so I gave the round to Porter for all the wrestling and mauling he did. JIM!"
Did you think Valuev beating Haye was a fair scorecard?Last edited by Dirk Diggler UK; 10-30-2015, 03:46 PM.Comment
-
I watched it again and realized how close it was.
Dirk and Laced Up as you may have notice are always trying so so hard to slander me and score imaginary points, this is just another chapter in the story.Last edited by Box-Office; 10-30-2015, 04:58 PM.Comment
-
Comment