Which boxer did the most damage to Mayweather? His physically toughest fight?

[Zaroku]

I'm starting to think it was Maidana who did more damage to Floyd. I just rewatched Mayweather-Maidana, Chino landed some brutal punches that I'm surprised Mayweather stood up to. He easily hit Mayweather with shots that would have knocked out other boxers.

You didn't need to watch it in slow motion, right?

Real time shows chino hitting Floyd all over the place.

Broner would have seen stopped by some of those shots chino hit Floyd with.

[Kigali]

Emanuel Augustus

[Zaroku]

I'd say Maidana. He bricked Floyd throughout the whole fight.
I can't speak for Floyd when he was younger. I know there was a fight where he went to war with a D-level guy.

Maidan a all the way! The nut cracker!

[punchr]

Damn was it really Maidana?! That's crazy that that would happen to Mayweather so late in his career.

[punchr]

I think it was Cotto. I'm watching the Cotto fight and Mayweather was getting his monkey ass hit, Cotto was making contact with Mayweather's body and head.

[punchr]

[punchr]

Maidana, Chavez, Castillo, Cotto, Augustus....


Margarito would have put him in a coffin. Styles make fights.

I think you're right. Look what Cotto did to Floyd. There's no punch Floyd could land that would stop Margarito from running him down, Floyd would have to rely on angles and conditioning

[elfag]

Maidana 1, it was competitive the entire fight and really made floyd work hard.


I havent watched JLC 1 in a long time so cant compared that.

Cotto made his nose bleed but mayweather solved cotto and busted him up really bad by the end of the fight, clearly won and was in control at the end.

Mosley almost dropped him but that just that round.

Augustus was crazy, Mayweather beat the snot out of him but he just kept coming and coming. Augustus got some in too on floyd because he is so awkward and comes from weird angles, floyd was winning but it was hard work.

Remembering the agustus fight and watching that chavez clip, its no wonder mayweather had some hand problems the way he is landing so hard on these guys skulls but they kept coming.

[elfag]

I think it was Cotto. I'm watching the Cotto fight and Mayweather was getting his monkey ass hit, Cotto was making contact with Mayweather's body and head.

Floyd was toying with cotto by the end of the fight. Not so with Maidana.

[Joe Beamish]

It was between Cotto and Maidana, but I have to say Maidana looked like he got to him more, After both those fights Floyd visibly looked like he was in a fight.

This. In both fights, Floyd looked like he was not enjoying himself, and his face showed it afterwards. The prime version of Floyd, even in the first Castillo fight, was totally unbothered, even when the going got rough.

Sugar Shane rocked him, but only briefly.