Who's undefeated record is more impressive Mayweather or Ottke

[SterlingStained]

Everyone is better than Jones as Jones was a 1/100th of his prime self when he fought Joe. Hopkins was about 1/50th of his peak.

I'm sure you will get a few dipsh-ts to respond to this as this is NSB.

As to my post, I think ottke and calzaghe have similar resumes, what say you?

who on floyd's resume is better than calzaghe's hopkins win?

[Mr.Fantastic]

Everyone is better than Jones as Jones was a 1/100th of his prime self when he fought Joe. Hopkins was about 1/50th of his peak.

I'm sure you will get a few dipsh-ts to respond to this as this is NSB.

As to my post, I think ottke and calzaghe have similar resumes, what say you?

I wasn't being serious but you can't go the prime route because Floyd didn't really fight anyone great in their prime, just like Calzaghe. Was Pac prime? Was DLH?

You guys give more credit to Floyd beating someone that already lost before and even if they lost worse.

[El-blanco]

Everyone is better than Jones as Jones was a 1/100th of his prime self when he fought Joe. Hopkins was about 1/50th of his peak.

I'm sure you will get a few dipsh-ts to respond to this as this is NSB.

As to my post, I think ottke and calzaghe have similar resumes, what say you?

Haha so what was pacquaio when Floyd beat him? Hopkins had better wins, before and after he lost to joe, than pacquaio did leading to the Floyd fight. He also wasn't ktfo.

Exactly, threads like this always remind me of what a bunch of whiny btches the Floydboys are. Then you got them coming in to cry "everyone is gonna pick the other guy because they hate Floyd waah"

How could one resist?

they're unbelievably insecure. If they truly believed Floyd was the best they wouldn't act this way.

[The Big Dunn]

I wasn't being serious but you can't go the prime route because Floyd didn't really fight anyone great in their prime, just like Calzaghe. Was Pac prime? Was DLH?

You guys give more credit to Floyd beating someone that already lost before and even if they lost worse.

Manny and ODH both controlled when they fought Floyd. Had they made different choices, they both would have fought Floyd when they were closer to "prime". Holding this against Floyd is like holding not fighting Bowe against Lennox or Martinez against GGG.

Since you weren't being serious, We can stop here. But I aminterested in who you think had a better resume-ottke or Calzaghe.

[BrometheusBob.]

Everyone is better than Jones as Jones was a 1/100th of his prime self when he fought Joe. Hopkins was about 1/50th of his peak.

I'm sure you will get a few dipsh-ts to respond to this as this is NSB.

As to my post, I think ottke and calzaghe have similar resumes, what say you?

I agree that Roy Jones was totally washed by that time but Hopkins was a solid win. Not better than everything on Floyd's resume level, but a good win.

[The Big Dunn]

Haha so what was pacquaio when Floyd beat him? Hopkins had better wins, before and after he lost to joe, than pacquaio did leading to the Floyd fight. He also wasn't ktfo.

they're unbelievably insecure. If they truly believed Floyd was the best they wouldn't act this way.

So a guy being ranked #2 or #3 p4p in the world and being the 2nd best ww in the world is 1/50th of his prime? Man GTFOH. See my response to Mr Fantastic.

[Elotero]

vote and discuss

ottke got a better ko than any of floyds

that ottke ko of mundine is sig worthy larry

[The Big Dunn]

I agree that Roy Jones was totally washed by that time but Hopkins was a solid win. Not better than everything on Floyd's resume level, but a good win.

Many think it wasn't a win at all. I'm cool with this, it was a good win.

[BrometheusBob.]

Manny and ODH both controlled when they fought Floyd. Had they made different choices, they both would have fought Floyd when they were closer to "prime". Holding this against Floyd is like holding not fighting Bowe against Lennox or Martinez against GGG.

Since you weren't being serious, We can stop here. But I aminterested in who you think had a better resume-ottke or Calzaghe.

When I assess a fighters resume I usually do not factor in why the fights happened when they did. The bottom line for me is who did this person fight, when did they fight, and how did they perform.

I don't care for instance why Lennox Lewis fought Mike Tyson when he did, all I know is he fought super washed up Tyson so I can't make much out of that performance. That might not be Lewis's fault, but that doesn't mean I should give him any more credit than the fight actually warrants.

[Mr.Fantastic]

Many think it wasn't a win at all. I'm cool with this, it was a good win.

Like Floyd vs Castillo 1?