Whose 49-0 is truly greater? Mayweather or Marciano?

[NChristo]

So according to the ELO, Ali's win over Moore was better than his win over Foreman?

.....Seems legit

I think it means that Archie was the higher ranked and better boxer going into his fight with Ali then Foreman was going in against Frazier.

Legit.

He's 2613 going against Ali.

[big_james10]

You should find someone who watched all of Marciano's 49 fights and all of Mayweather's 49 fights and ask them. That is the only way you can truly get a fair assessment of this asinine question.

[Elroy1]

Champion in the era of Ezzard Charles, Joe Walcott, and Archie Moore is the weakest? HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHA!!!!!!

But for real.

Boxrec:

Archie Moore #1 p4p all time.
Ezzard Charles #4 p4p all time.

Weakest era...

Lb for lb- None of those guys were HW's and neither was Marciano.

But the point is really that lb for lb, none of those guys is as good as a modern fighter the same size, not even close!

I'd seriously doubt that Rocky could even land a glove on Floyd h2h and win despite the weight difference!!

And basically these listings serve only to prove that boxrec ratings are totally worthless.

[Bull24]

Mayweather never was an undisputed champion. Never fought anyone favored to beat him. Never fought anyone on the same level as Charles and Walcott.

But he looked good against Baldomir and Berto

[Avenge Myself]

I'd seriously doubt that Rocky could even land a glove on Floyd h2h and win despite the weight difference!!

Rocky was knocking heavyweights out the ring and giving them brain tumors, sometimes breaking their arms and shoulders with the force of his punches. The first time Rocky touches Floyd anywhere on his little body Floyd is going to be seriously hurt.

You flowmoles are truly the most pathetic fanbase in the history of the sweet sport!

[Avenge Myself]

Still waiting for any flowmole to name just ONE victory Floyd had that tops Rocky Marciano's KO win over Joe Louis, who is to this day still ranked as the #1 Heavyweight in history as well as the greatest puncher of all time by most boxing experts and websites.

And don't tell me Joe Louis was past it, as if Dela Hoya and Mosley weren't, as if Pacquiao hadn't already been KTFO in 6.

[Mr.Fantastic]

Really?

??????????? Really?

Yes really.

[Yodpayak]

Mayweather has much more skill. Thats most important. Best at heavyweight is only the best of 1% of people.

[Avenge Myself]

Fact is, Marciano knocking out men like Joe Louis (#1 heavyweight of all time) as well as legends of the sport like Archie Moore and Ezzard Charles >>>>>>>>>>> Floyd's lame decision wins over Oscar, Manny, and Mosley.

The only argument you flowmoles have is that Joe Louis, Moore, and Walcott were old when Rocky KO'ed them, yet Pacquiao was 3-2 in his last 5 fights and KTFO in 6 when Floyd finally grew a pair and fought him. Oscar had just been KTFO by Hopkins when Floyd choose him. This is truly the most hypocritical and shameless fan base I have ever seen in my life!

Oh and Floyd is a drug cheat! Remember that!

[Avenge Myself]

While Rocky is knocking legendary icons like Joe Louis out of the ring at Heavyweight, Fraud Mayweather's only knock out in the past 5 years came with a sucker punch over Vicious Victoria Ortiz!

Which sounds greater- Getting to 49 and 0 by knocking all time great heavyweights unconscious, or getting to 49 and 0 by running, hugging, crying and sucker punching?