Comments Thread For: Sulaiman Sees Mayweather in Top Five of All-Time

[Luilun]

Anyone tied to steriod use should not be on the list and this includes Holyfield Mosley Toney and of course Mayweather

[Pigeons]

Wtf are you objective lol

They can't even recognize their reflections anymore. Floyd has robbed them of their identity.

IMO Floyd is top 20. A lineal MW title would put him in the top 10.

[Fetta]

I dont like to rank era to era or include fighters i have never seen and just heard of (Grieb for example) but with Floyd retiring i found that there is no clear 1 after him. Floyd is a "once-in-a-lifetime" talent in boxing. He is along side the ATG's

[The plunger man]

Suliaman should stick to what he loves doing best....and that's munching on burgers and nachos......oi suliaman you chumley shut it

[texasboi15]

Anyone tied to steriod use should not be on the list and this includes Holyfield Mosley Toney and of course Mayweather

You're missing one you dumb fck you make it so obvious u fckin lame.

[!! Shawn]

I rank Mayweather 3rd on my All-Time List. He defeated more World Champions than any other boxer, He defeated 6x Hall of Famers (Cotto, Dela Hoya, Marquez, Pacman, Gatti, Mosley), and he defeated 3x Undefeated Boxers (Canelo, Hatton, Corrales). How is this Cherry Picking?

People forget Marquez was #3 P4P at the time....Mosley was #2 P4P....Canelo was consider a risk....Hatton was undefeated.

And don't give me they weren't in thier prime BS: Pacman fought Mosely and Hatton after they fought Mayweather and everyone gave him credit. Marquez KOed Pacman after the Mayweather fight. Cotto was the Jr MW Champion. Dela Hoya was his first fight at 154.

Marquez was a 135lber who moved up two wieght classes to fight at a catchweight of 142, which floyd blew off, and came in at 147.

That win seriously needs an asterisk next to it.

[imperial1]

Marquez was a 135lber who moved up two wieght classes to fight at a catchweight of 142, which floyd blew off, and came in at 147.

That win seriously needs an asterisk next to it.

Can't use common sense against Mayweather fans .Also Floyd's fight night weight was never reported so he could have came in at around 150 or above

[Southpaw93]

I rank Mayweather 3rd on my All-Time List. He defeated more World Champions than any other boxer, He defeated 6x Hall of Famers (Cotto, Dela Hoya, Marquez, Pacman, Gatti, Mosley), and he defeated 3x Undefeated Boxers (Canelo, Hatton, Corrales). How is this Cherry Picking?

People forget Marquez was #3 P4P at the time....Mosley was #2 P4P....Canelo was consider a risk....Hatton was undefeated.

And don't give me they weren't in thier prime BS: Pacman fought Mosely and Hatton after they fought Mayweather and everyone gave him credit. Marquez KOed Pacman after the Mayweather fight. Cotto was the Jr MW Champion. Dela Hoya was his first fight at 154.

lol nice try

[Jsmooth9876]

Here's his other 4
Chavez sr
Chavez jr
canelo
Marquez

Or replace any of those with another Mexican name

[wlliam]

Marquez was a 135lber who moved up two wieght classes to fight at a catchweight of 142, which floyd blew off, and came in at 147.

That win seriously needs an asterisk next to it.

It does have an asterisk next to it and believe me nobody will ever forget that part...ever.