Floyd is #7 All time according to a "fair and objective site"

[Jc8804]

Why no poll Larry. Who cares about a dumb site. Find out what we think. Someone already did. There should be aaster. Moag said top 30-40

[LacedUp]

Seems fair.

Seems objective.

Tiger at #9. I love that.

I saw that too.

#CredibilityCemented

[Khalid X]

Floyd is defiantly top 10. After a few years pass, I'm sure he will be top 5 or top 3 on the ATG list.

IMHO
1. Sugar Ray Robinson
2. Henry Armstrong
3. Willie Pep
4. Floyd Mayweather Jr.
5. Muhammad Ali

[LacedUp]

Most likely to me, 35-45.. But that's just estimation after a 10 minute think!

What I do know is that right now, I most certainly would not have him above Bernard Hopkins on my ATG list

Then your list would have absolutely no credibility.

[Khalid X]

Before anyone accuses me of being biased......I was one of the biggest Pacquiao fans on this site and went hard on those Floyd fans back in the day.

However Floyd not only beat but dominated Juan Manual Marquez, Ricky Hatton, Oscar De La Hoya, Canelo, Cotto and other top fighters. He also had a clear win over Pacquiao, who I consider a top 15 ATG.

All that being said.....people suck off old fighters on this site to sound cool. Mayweather is better than Hearns, Haglar, Leonard and Duran. Not only that, putting hate aside....he has had a better career than most want to admit.

I have him top 5 All-time, and this is from someone who doesn't like him as a person or a fighter.

[Pigeons]

I wonder where Tyson is on that list?
::Checks list::

#22 HW, #145 all-time.
BoxRec is not impressed.

[.!WAR MIKEY!.]

[IMG]http://i1158.***********.com/albums/p615/ace22/1234_zpsuy1r9yg6.png[/IMG]

according to Freedom this is a fair and objective site....http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/sh...d.php?t=688577

boxrec lol good laugh.

[boliodogs]

All just opinion that can't be proven one way or the other. If you think Mayweather is the best boxer to ever put on gloves then to you he is and you are correct. If you think he has no place in the top 1000 boxers in history then that's the right answer for you.