Floyd is #7 All time according to a "fair and objective site"

[BrometheusBob.]

The point is its not fair and it's not balanced.

It's terrible and illogical hence why Floyd is considered #1 WW of all time.

He tried to use it to support his argument when the very same "fair and objective" ranking system (laughable) has Floyd #7 of all time, something he doesn't agree with and is now making excuses for.

Very easy to follow.

Follow up question, suppose I made a scoring system that gives everyone +1 point for win, -1 for loss. The results will be ******, but the scoring is nevertheless absolutely consistent and is fair in that it treats everyone identically.

Now being "fair" and "consistent" isn't proof that the rankings are good. BoxRec is equally fair and consistent as my above hypothetical scoring mechanism, but that alone doesn't it make it any more or less good a rating system. (You'd have to argue that the particular way the scoring is performed has value, which Freedom did not do.)

[DannyNL]

Floyd > Archie Moore

Floyd > everyone

[Furn]

Joe Calzaghe must be top 10 then.

[The Gambler1981]

Using just boxrec alone as a source though

[Larry the boss]

So Tunney basically caught a ban in his zeal defending Boxrecs fairness and objectivity.

Said website has Mayweather #7 all time.

If that is not 100 percent self ownage then what is it???lol

[Larry the boss]

If Mayweathers "top 10-15 in your book" then I'd be curious to know how many fighters "Are in your book"...

How does your list look?

[toshmurph]

How does your list look?

Most likely to me, 35-45.. But that's just estimation after a 10 minute think!

What I do know is that right now, I most certainly would not have him above Bernard Hopkins on my ATG list

[Æthelstan]

top 25 but not top 10.. opposition wasn't good enough

[Jc8804]

[IMG]http://i1158.***********.com/albums/p615/ace22/1234_zpsuy1r9yg6.png[/IMG]

according to Freedom this is a fair and objective site....http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/sh...d.php?t=688577

Stop with this dumb nonsense.

90 percent of everyone here thinks he is a cheater . no way he is top 10 .gtfoh

Mods delete this thread already and make master thread with a poll.

No one cares about another site

[tangalog2200]

[IMG]http://i1158.***********.com/albums/p615/ace22/1234_zpsuy1r9yg6.png[/IMG]

according to Freedom this is a fair and objective site....http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/sh...d.php?t=688577

i don't care about that site....

i give you more credibility than them..so where is floyd at all time, larry?