is Miguel Cotto a Top 15 All-Time Great ?

[STEELHEAD]

IDK but Cotto is a Legend

[QballLobo]

Where is Left Hook Tua when you need him?

[boliodogs]

I don't think he is an all time great at all. If he is then so is Austin Trout and Antonio Margarito. He is a very good fighter but I don't think he is an all time great. If someone thinks he is an all time great they have every right to their opinion. Stuff like this is impossible to prove one way or the other and just comes down to opinions anyway.

[joesaiditstrue]

jesus christ HELL no, are you this ignorant lol

[joesaiditstrue]

I don't think he is an all time great at all. If he is then so is Austin Trout and Antonio Margarito. He is a very good fighter but I don't think he is an all time great. If someone thinks he is an all time great they have every right to their opinion. Stuff like this is impossible to prove one way or the other and just comes down to opinions anyway.

literally the *only* argument for Cotto being anything more than a great fighter is his 4 titles in 4 weight classes, the problem is look at who he fought to win those belts

[soul_survivor]

Cotto holds some good wins but he has lost his biggest fights and his resurgence is built around beating a badly injured Martinez. Whether or not he is an ATG is up for debate but is he top 10-15? Noway.

[BattlingNelson]

He's TSBE!

Teh Second Bestest Eva!

[New England]

Why not. ATG is some scifi fantasy subjective bull**** anyway.

because it's incredibly easy to name 15 fighters better than miguel cotto if you know WTF you are talking about.

[NachoMan]

At what? Boxing?

Nice!!

[NachoMan]

All time great Puerto Rican Welterweight? Probably.