How Many Losses Does Mayweather Really Have?

[FlatLine]

A robbery is a fight in which it is very difficult to objectively score the fight in favor of the one who won the fight on the official scorecards.

A fight that can be scored for both participants objectively is just that, a close fight. That's what Castillo-Mayweather 1 was.

Well the term robbery is subjective itself and doesn't necessarily mean that it has to be a lopsided performance by one participant. Even a 7-5 fight can termed a "robbery" by some viewers. Now there are varying degrees of robberies which is where we attach a prefix such as "bad robbery", "harsh robbery" or "insane robbery" etc..

[Mr. 29K]

4.


Castillo

De La Hoya

Maidana

Cotto

[BKM-2010]

Well the term robbery is subjective itself and doesn't necessarily mean that it has to be a lopsided performance by one participant. Even a 7-5 fight can termed a "robbery" by some viewers. Now there are varying degrees of robberies which is where we attach a prefix such as "bad robbery", "harsh robbery" or "insane robbery" etc..

There's your problem. You say 7-5 in a matter of fact type of way. That's still an opinion and it indicates that the fight is very close. If people are dis*****g a decision where a guy won by only 2 rounds it can likely be scored for the guy who lost the fight too. That is not a robbery. It's a close fight where either man could have won.

Some fights are not close fights that either man could have won. Those are the robberies.

[BluesMan]

As coach Bill Parcells once said,''you are what your record says you are''.

Therefore,the answer is none....read it and weep.

[Scary]

The first Castillo fight was close, could've gone either way.

Maidana I was also really close, could've gone either way.

I voted still undefeated.

[-PBP-]

I think he has 12 losses:

Reggie Sanders
Castillo
Angel Manfredy (BS stoppage. Manfredy would have kod'd him)
Zab Judah
DeMarcus Corley
De LA Hoya
Carlos Baldomir
Canelo (CJ Ross was the only one watching the fight)
Paul Williams (ducks = losses)
Cotto
Mosley
Maidana

[BrometheusBob.]

I think he has 12 losses:

Reggie Sanders
Castillo
Angel Manfredy (BS stoppage. Manfredy would have kod'd him)
Zab Judah
DeMarcus Corley
De LA Hoya
Carlos Baldomir
Canelo (CJ Ross was the only one watching the fight)
Paul Williams (ducks = losses)
Cotto
Mosley
Maidana

Dam the fact that Reggie Sanders made your list and Pacquiao didn't hurts.

[Spoon23]

The first Castillo fight was close, could've gone either way.

Maidana I was also really close, could've gone either way.

I voted still undefeated.

No it wasn't.

[Spoon23]

he lost to castillo, should have been dq'd in the judah fight, de la hoya, should have been dq'd in the ortiz fight, lost to cotto, guerrero, canelo, both maidana fights, and the pacquiao fight. so 10 losses.

Come to think of it you have a point with the Ortiz fight. Sucker punching is just *****.

Dang Floyd's resume is full of holes.

[Caught Square]

No it wasn't.

Ah so compubox is the truth when it's convinient eh?



Can't have it both ways. You thought Pacquiao won right?