Which of These Two Fighters do You Have Ranked Higher All-Time RIGHT NOW?

[HanzGruber]

If manny beats Jesse Vargas then he might be TBE

[LoadedWraps]

If manny beats Jesse Vargas then he might be TBE

[LoadedWraps]

Strong bump of peace.

[Tony Trick-Pony]

Really, I have to go with Pac. He fought Morales when Morales still had a lot left, had one close fight and then took him out twice- something never done before. He took down an admittedly older Barrera by still, he dominated him twice, the second fight right before Barrera all but beat Marquez. And of course, Marquez. He beat him 3 out of 4 and I know a lot of people don't agree with that. Still, the first two fights were close and he dropped him more than anybody else has and at the ending of the fourth fight, a blown up Marquez wasn't in the best shape. Pac had done some clear damage and of course, Marquez wouldn't give him a fifth fight. Pac also took on a prime Bradley three times and beat him pretty much every time. He fought a prime Rios and beat him like he owned him. He beat the hell out of Margarito and Cotto. The guy fought everybody and didn't care what point they were at in their careers. That's exceptional.

Mayweather didn't fight many prime guys. You could say Hatton. Maybe Cotto, although that was after the Pac pummeling. Guerrero maybe but it's Guerrero. Ortiz, but it's Ortiz. DLH, Mosley, Pac were all past it. Even past it, Pac faced Bradly three times. Why didn't Mayweather ever fight Bradley? Would have been way better than Berto, Guerrero or Ortiz.

I have to go with Pac.

[Tony Trick-Pony]

Off topic but since you brought it up in your own thread I would put b hop above floyd in all time list. And that's not taking anything away from Floyd. But b hop has fought everyone in between Trinidad to Kovalev, including Trinidad and Kovalev, when Trinidad and kovalev were both at their height.

But in topic I would hold Floyd higher than pac. But that's not to take anything from pac either As another poster states pac's path has been unique

Floyd is amazing no Doudt. But I would hold him second to none if he fought. and beat pac and cotto in their primes. However he beat them both without a doubt.

Hopkins definitely fought Tito when Tito was at the top. That's what's missing from Mayweather's record.

Actually, this seems to be a common thing with retired unbeaten guys. Calzaghe beat a lot of guys past it as well. I think he was exceptional. Don't get me wrong, but Jones and Hopkins were both over the hell when he fought them. I think Eubank was as well, although not as badly. Marciano's record is the same. The "0" looks great but it often lacks substance.

[BM dnobagaV]

How is he a former fighter of the decade? Won't that title always stick with him lmao

[LoadedWraps]

How is he a former fighter of the decade? Won't that title always stick with him lmao

Good point. I added "former" because it was the last decade, not the current one, but I get your point, and yea, the title is forever.

[LoadedWraps]

Bumped, for NSB.

[Emanuelg]

Both have controversial wins difference many controversy wins are only with one guys if not mistaken

[LoadedWraps]

Both have controversial wins difference many controversy wins are only with one guys if not mistaken

Wait....what?