Who should be Maidana's comeback fight?

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Damiens
    Contender
    • Jun 2015
    • 106
    • 6
    • 2
    • 6,198

    #1

    Who should be Maidana's comeback fight?

    I'd be very interested in seeing Maidana make a return to the ring, especially on PBC where he'd put on a barn-burner of a performance like he always does. He'd help PBC ratings tremendously. There is no order in the list below. Maidana is coming off 2 losses and hasn't fought in a year. Fighting some of these guys listed below could mean a 3rd loss due to being overweight and inactivity. I believe he needs a tune-up fight first. We might see a Maidana who gasses in under 4 rounds due to cutting too much weight too fast and draining himself. I thought the perfect comeback fight for Maidana was Andre Berto, but Floyd seemingly needed to fight Berto for some reason lol.



    Devon Alexander - A rare opportunity to avenge a loss and Devon's clinch tactics may frustrate Maidana again or will Maidana 2.0 be enough to defeat this seemingly regressed version of Alexander?

    Robert Guerrero - A comeback fight against a guy who doesn't back down. Fight will surely be fireworks for however long it lasts. Guerrero hasn't looked good ever since his loss to Floyd Mayweather

    Chris Algieri - Good test for a Maidana who is out of shape and hasn't fought in a year. It will also show how Algieri deals with a real pressure fighter and not just a come-forward plodder like Provodnikov who's defense is his face. Algieri is also on record saying Maidana punches tremendously harder than Ruslan Provodnikov with EITHER hand.

    Luis Collazo - Collazo showed that he could use his experience to trouble Thurman a bit. However, Maidana is an experienced veteran like Collazo himself and if a simple cut made Collazo quit, I wonder if Collazo would have the heart to stay in there after Maidana lands the bombs that usually rearrange his opponent's face

    Danny Garcia - Garcia is trying to find validation after his controversial fights with the 75th ranked fighter at lightweight Rod Salka, Mauricio Herrera, Lamont Peterson and fans think he cherrypicked Malignaggi. A win over Maidana would help Garcia regain the fan's respect. However, it's a dangerous fight as he faces the possibility of taking his first L

    Shawn Porter - Has a somewhat similar style to Maidana, albeit less tricky and not as experienced, but younger and faster. The possible FOTY for however long it lasts

    Keith Thurman - Turning into somewhat of a glass cannon with recent performances. A lot of firepower but doesn't seem to have the mental fortitude to get into a tough fight as he instantly retreats as soon as he gets clipped. Something Maidana would love to do is rough-up and frustrate the fast-rising star. Very good for Thurman's career to get a W but also dangerous.

    Kell Brook - Somewhat of a stylistic nightmare for Maidana since Kell is a heavy-handed counter-puncher but we've seen him hurt against lesser opposition. Would be the biggest fight of Kell Brook's career and a Maidana coming off 2 losses and inactivity would make it the perfect time for Brook to look for this fight

    Diego Chaves - Maidana is on record saying that when he fought Diego Chaves (they trained together in Argentina), Chaves did not know what to do. Maidana claims pressuring him was the key to defeating Chaves

    Amir Khan - Again, another rare opportunity to avenge a loss for Maidana. The first fight was FOTY, and now both fighters have improved drastically from their previous fights. However, with Khan's fight against Algieri, Khan seemed troubled by Algieri's pressure. But maybe Algieri just caught Khan off-guard with his new style. Would be a very interesting fight and a possibly small-scale superfight

    Honorable Mention


    Adrien Broner Rematch - I personally have no interest in this rematch, but I've seen many people wanting to see it again. Most people just want to see Broner get beat up and hospitalized again, but there are a few who think Broner wins a rematch because he simply 'underestimated' Maidana.
    32
    Devon Alexander
    0.00%
    0
    Robert Guerrero
    25.00%
    8
    Chris Algieri
    12.50%
    4
    Luis Collazo
    6.25%
    2
    Danny Garcia
    21.88%
    7
    Shawn Porter
    6.25%
    2
    Keith Thurman
    12.50%
    4
    Kell Brook
    0.00%
    0
    Diego Chaves
    3.13%
    1
    Amir Khan
    12.50%
    4
    Last edited by Damiens; 08-11-2015, 10:54 AM.
  • BostonGuy
    Emeritus Champion
    Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
    • Feb 2008
    • 13343
    • 2,119
    • 6,833
    • 900,690,265

    #2
    I'd be surprised if he fought any of those guys on the list. I think the sensible thing would be to take a 'tuneup' fight against a soft touch opponent.

    Comment

    • Larry the boss
      EDUCATED
      Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
      • Jan 2011
      • 90798
      • 6,419
      • 4,473
      • 2,500,480

      #3
      Pacquiao..

      Comment

      • trixx12
        Interim Champion
        Gold Champion - 500-1,000 posts
        • Sep 2013
        • 511
        • 28
        • 40
        • 6,750

        #4
        I want Maidana to Kick Danny Gift Garcia's ass.

        Comment

        • NEETzsche
          Undisputed Champion
          Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
          • Oct 2011
          • 8389
          • 283
          • 176
          • 29,441

          #5
          garcia or thurman would be the most interesting opponents imo. i think he should take a tune-up first though, and maybe consider moving to jmw

          Comment

          • TBear
            Lords of Boxingscene
            Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
            • Apr 2008
            • 113275
            • 6,079
            • 12,778
            • 1,665,677,098

            #6
            Of course all this is assuming Maidana is at the same weight as he was before.

            Comment

            • bigtyivier2k2
              Interim Champion
              Gold Champion - 500-1,000 posts
              • Apr 2014
              • 566
              • 167
              • 3
              • 74,941

              #7
              Thurman, or Garcia.

              I doubt chino will be as good as he was the last 4-5 fights he had because of the long layoff coupled with a huge weight gain. I think the inactivity along with having to lose all that weight will take a toll on him. Would be surprised if a top 5 ww wipes him out.

              Comment

              • trixx12
                Interim Champion
                Gold Champion - 500-1,000 posts
                • Sep 2013
                • 511
                • 28
                • 40
                • 6,750

                #8
                Originally posted by NEETzsche
                garcia or thurman would be the most interesting opponents imo. i think he should take a tune-up first though, and maybe consider moving to jmw
                Without tune up fight he can beat Danny Gift Garcia.

                Comment

                • Damiens
                  Contender
                  • Jun 2015
                  • 106
                  • 6
                  • 2
                  • 6,198

                  #9
                  Originally posted by BostonGuy
                  I'd be surprised if he fought any of those guys on the list. I think the sensible thing would be to take a 'tuneup' fight against a soft touch opponent.
                  Maidana said he'd only fight a big name. Robert Guerrero and Devon Alexander are tuneups for Maidana since they're both at the bottom of the big names list.

                  Comment

                  • Damiens
                    Contender
                    • Jun 2015
                    • 106
                    • 6
                    • 2
                    • 6,198

                    #10
                    I'm surprised someone voted Diego Chaves. That was more of a trick option since that fight isn't even possible haha xD

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    TOP