Rank your Wleterweights

[Szef]

so...of like the 90% of posters who thought Thurman was the 3rd best welterweight on the planet...any changes in mind or you just gonna stay butthurt and in denial?

it's still between him and brook, to me at least.

so he got hurt by a body shot, big ****in deal..

[BrometheusBob.]

1. Mayweather

2. Pacquiao

3. Thurman

4. Maidana

5. Vargas

6. Brook

7. Bradley

8. Alexander

9. Rios

10. Porter
.

LMAOOOOOO, Boxeo stay trippin.

And wait, Porter #10? Beating Broner gets him no cred?

1. Mayweather

2. Pacquiao

3. Thurman

4. Brook

5. Khan

6. Porter

7. Bradley

8. Alexander


Maidana and Marquez have been inactive, so I didn't rate them

Can't decide on #9,10... some people arguably in contention would be Chavez, Vargas, Broner, Sadam Ali, Rios, Guerrero? Kind of tough call because none of these guys seem competitive with the above 8.

EDIT:
Gonna man up and make some calls here...
#9 Rios
#10 Chavez

[soul_survivor]

it's still between him and brook, to me at least.

so he got hurt by a body shot, big ****in deal..

on what basis? he struggled against a guy handled easily by khan. he looked lost against bundu and he was on and off against guerrero (good fight though). a number 3 welterweight should be schooling or battering these guys. bradley schooled jmm, won almost every round against vargas and hurt latinos so bad, they are still living off of one punch lol that's an umber 3 welterweight.

try again.

[Earl-Hickey]

Mayweather
Brook
Pacquiao
Bradley
Thurman

[gmc_rfc_06]

Mayweather
Brook
Pacquiao
Thurman
Bradley
Maidana (although he may not be a WW ever again)
Porter
Khan

[Szef]

on what basis? he struggled against a guy handled easily by khan. he looked lost against bundu and he was on and off against guerrero (good fight though). a number 3 welterweight should be schooling or battering these guys. bradley schooled jmm, won almost every round against vargas and hurt latinos so bad, they are still living off of one punch lol that's an umber 3 welterweight.

try again.

When did Bradley beat JMM? This isn't 2013 anymore. He schooled Vargas? You mean he won every round (which he didin't) but got hurt once (which he did)? Sounds familliar, don't you think?

And GTFO with your triangle theories, "Khan beat Colazzo easily, Thurman should of killed him"

"A number 3 WW should be schooling or battering these guys"

Nice opinion. Luckily nobody gives a **** about it.

Try again.

[soul_survivor]

Mayweather
Brook
Pacquiao
Thurman
Bradley
Maidana (although he may not be a WW ever again)
Porter
Khan

surley porter, bradley and even maidana have done more than thurman? argument can be made for khan too.

[soul_survivor]

When did Bradley beat JMM? This isn't 2013 anymore. He schooled Vargas? You mean he won every round (which he didin't) but got hurt once (which he did)? Sounds familliar, don't you think?

And GTFO with your triangle theories, "Khan beat Colazzo easily, Thurman should of killed him"

"A number 3 WW should be schooling or battering these guys"

Nice opinion. Luckily nobody gives a **** about it.

Try again.

Khans easy win over Alexander is superior to Thurmans win over anyone.

so, we don't just base rankings off what happened today. Bradley has been the 3rd best welter for some 2-3 years now. For thurman to knock him off that pedastal, he actually has to win a real title, Even Porter has done more.

stop posting smilies, it doesnt make ur argument any better. gtfo.

[gmc_rfc_06]

surley porter, bradley and even maidana have done more than thurman? argument can be made for khan too.

Bradley has done more, but he's also looked vulnerable since Provodnikov and I don't believe he is big enough for 147. I'd have Bradley losing to just about every other name I listed.

Thurman has looked shaky at times, but he does have KO's over Diego Chavez, Soto Karass, Diaz and a solid win over Guerrero.

[soul_survivor]

Bradley has done more, but he's also looked vulnerable since Provodnikov and I don't believe he is big enough for 147. I'd have Bradley losing to just about every other name I listed.

Thurman has looked shaky at times, but he does have KO's over Diego Chavez, Soto Karass, Diaz and a solid win over Guerrero.

Bradley hast he better wins...KOing Karass means nothing at the time they fought (thurman that is).