What was the toughest fight of Floyd Mayweather's career?

[SugarRayCurtain]

No mention of Pacquiao specifically? lol. Strong bias poll.
Guy wins 4 rounds and if you watched the fight extremely close could have given him more. He also hurts Floyd on 2 occasions and Mayweathers connect percentage is the lowest of his entire career.

How the **** does Cotto give Mayweather a tougher fight

[punchr]

No mention of Pacquiao specifically? lol. Strong bias poll.
Guy wins 4 rounds and if you watched the fight extremely close could have given him more. He also hurts Floyd on 2 occasions and Mayweathers connect percentage is the lowest of his entire career.

How the **** does Cotto give Mayweather a tougher fight

How is the poll biased? I included a "Someone else." option. If you think that Manny was Mayweather's toughest fight choose that option. But honestly that fight was a disgrace.

Btw, Pac did not bust up Mayweather the way Cotto did. Pac just gave Mayweather a little bump on his lip; whereas Miguel busted up Floyd's face.

[punchr]

Need to distinguish btw physically the toughest versus closest imo, as they nwcessarily don't go hand in hand.

Physically the toughest? Have to go with Augustus, Maidana and perhaps Cotto then Castillo in that order.

Closest is Castillo despite the wide card, followed by Maidana 1, where score was prettt good. ODLH fight was not close at all despite the post fight narrative and official scorecard.

I didn't say "closest," I said "toughest" so physically toughest fight.

[b00g13man]

No mention of Pacquiao specifically? lol. Strong bias poll.
Guy wins 4 rounds and if you watched the fight extremely close could have given him more. He also hurts Floyd on 2 occasions and Mayweathers connect percentage is the lowest of his entire career.

How the **** does Cotto give Mayweather a tougher fight

Looooool. Cotto actually took Floyd out of his comfort zone. #48, not so much.

On topic, it's Castillo.

[sargo]

The one where he got booed the most.

[IronDanHamza]

Castillo 1 or Maidana 1.

They're the only fights he's had that could have gone either way.

[punchr]

Castillo 1 or Maidana 1.

They're the only fights he's had that could have gone either way.

Most physically tough fight. Not closest.

[I Love Jesus!]

ALL Gayweather did against cotto was run

[NEETzsche]

de la hoya and cotto made him think the hardest, while castillo and maidana made him fight the hardest

[SugarRayCurtain]

Looooool. Cotto actually took Floyd out of his comfort zone. #48, not so much.

On topic, it's Castillo.

Yea by landing a few jabs and bodyshots
And somehow Floyd getting hurt twice, losing 4 rounds and having the lowest connect percentage of his entire career against Pacquiao is still in Floyds comfort zone?