Exposing the inaccuracy of Compubox

[Rath]

my summary of the fight from analyzing it in depth. pac clearly won 6 rounds: 3,4,6,7,8, and 10. floyd clearly won 5 rounds: 1,2,5,11,12. The 9th round really was a toss up if i had to lean i would probably give it to pac for simply landing the harder punches. An even round is also fine and giving it to floyd isn't wrong at all. So my card would be either 7-5 pac, 6-5-1 even pac or a draw 6-6.

my reasoning: round 3 a lot of people seem to give to floyd but I can't see why. pac outlanded him in total punches, power punches, and had the best punch of the round. round 6 floyd actually outlanded pac 15-14 but most of floyd's punches were jabs while all of pacs were power to the head and body and he also had floyd wobbled. A clear example of a round where quality over quantity trumps. Round 8 was also an example of quality over quantity as floyd outlanded pac 11-9 but pac stunned him with 3 great flush punches. floyd's power punches lacked any authority or flushness in this round and pac landed the 3 best punches of the round that slightly troubled floyd so I think he deserves this round.

was that score card on facebook real authentic NSAC score card of the fight,
where the red corner won the fight where Floyd was on blue corner?

[b00g13man]

I have slow-motion. I have replay. They don't.

That changes nothing. Your numbers are there with no evidence to back it up.

[ReIoaded]

Great thread.

Definitely hardcore. Casual fans around here will probably trash the numbers, but maybe they can make videos about it

[jas]

Most people, including on these forums know little about boxing.

So they just listen to commentary and agree with whatever is being said

Most Floyd and pacquaio fans on this forum rarely watch fights involving other fighters - I'm not hating- I'm just trying to tell it how it is

Pacs injury clearly affected him and gave Floyd a mental edge

Floyd kept moving to his left and nearly always moves off to his left after a check hook when he's on the ropes. Pacs right hook was key. Floyd's moves have become somewhat predictable and manny read him well. Slipped right hands well and manny isn't known for being able to slip punches well.


Floyd planned to throw a lot of body shots but was limited to doing so in the fight because he was wary of getting countered

Floyd used his legs and reach. He was a good athlete in the fight.

When Floyd ducked low vs maidana, maidana would hit him on the back of the head

[daggum]

That changes nothing. Your numbers are there with no evidence to back it up.

Ok well you don't have to believe me. I know I made the most unbiased finding that I could because I really don't care who wins. I care about the truth. Did I miss a punch here or there? yea probably but I tried my best because I actually like boxing and this was fun and informative for me. I didn't believe the numbers and now I have my own evidence that they were wrong.

[Vasyl’s dad]

Oh wow you're still here?

Who are you and why are you asking if I'm still here? I'm a boxing fan. Why wouldn't I be here?

[Rath]

Great thread.

Definitely hardcore. Casual fans around here will probably trash the numbers, but maybe they can make videos about it

they shoot down op observation at first few pages because they thought op will make it look like Pac won on punch landed, jabs, and body shots.

now that it was a fair observation, they still shoot it down because Floyd lost in his stats.

and the shocking thing was Floyd fans wants video evidence of his observation, but don't want video evidence of Floyd's random drug test in his fight against Pac.

[bobotnaman]

did you count Floyd's punches while he was holding Pacquiao?

[daggum]

some more odds and ends: when counting punches I gave floyd a lot of credit for jabs that barely made contact with pac's face. I guess technically they did touch him but for me in a real punch the glove should at least fold up a little when the point of impact occurs and not just wipe the sweat off of your opponent. Floyd did land a lot of good scoring jabs as well but a lot of them were also the does that count? type of punch. Also punching your opponents gloves doens't count as a scoring punch do i even need to mention this?

some people are saying that floyd used the check hook over and over? this is just my guess after just watching it but he landed about 5 in the fight.

as far as counting the clinching and bending over. I had so many numbers going that I stopped counting but my running total was 21 clinches and 35 bending below the waist and I believe i stopped counting with a couple rounds to go.

[ganthet]

Why is it so funny? The dude is actually posting something interesting. He's using technology to break down a very carefully fought boxing match.

The only funny thing here is your basketball cartoons

Yeah I don't get the logic and purpose of that post as well. The OP is putting the time and effort to present his thorough analysis with the help of technology. Who knows how many slo-mos he kept on rewinding just to get a conclusive opinion whether the punch was clean or not. And doing that over and over again is freaking tiresome and takes alot of time.

Posting nothing more than a "hahahahahahahahaha" on a thread like this is not only childish but simply pathetic. The least you could do is take the time and effort to do what the OP did and then post your own analysis.

I for one am sure that judges probably got some punches wrong (mistaking a blocked/missed punch for a hit; and mistaking a connecting punch for a miss). Who knows just how many they truly got wrong.

But I can't really blame them since they don't have the benefit of slo-mo replay before scoring a punch. I myself thought that not one of Manny's punches during his flurry landed on Floyd when he was doing the high guard. I thought for sure not a single one connected. Until I saw a clear pic of Manny's punch penetrating the side of Floyd's high guard and hitting him right smack in the side of the face.