Who came closer to taking the 0?

[MisterPullman]

Maidana beat Floyd, that's why there had to be a rematch. Should of been at least a draw, that first fight was devastating.

Maidana is my favorite WW


But credit to Floyd for showing who's the better of the two in the rematch

[therealpugilist]

Maidana beat Floyd, that's why there had to be a rematch. Should of been at least a draw, that first fight was devastating.

Maidana is my favorite WW


But credit to Floyd for showing who's the better of the two in the rematch

I don't know who taught you how to score fights but in no way shape or form did Maidana win 6 rounds


If you give him the close rounds he loses 7-5

Mayweather clearly won 8 rounds to 4


Maidana did well in the first 4-5 rounds but he was getting clearly outboxed, outpunched and was tired after such a valiant effort



not saying that you do, but a lot of judges and fans score rounds for fighters who did better than they were expected too.....that's how and why we've had a lot of bs decisions


Maidana did well but he definitely had to do more to win

[therealpugilist]

Oscar stopped a ton of HOFers

Oscar did not stop a ton of hall of famers


He stopped a washed up Chavez, Barely beat past prime Whitaker by decision in a fight that was closer than his fight with Floyd, Gatti shouldn't even be in the hall of fame...he is the worst selection....McGuigan may be worse for the little he did.....Vargas may get in the hall, Gatti got in....Hector Camacho saw the final bell.....you might want to go do your homework bruh

[Boxing Goat]

Just like I thought. You resort to name calling because you realise how ******ed that comment was. Nice playing with you ****tard.

Speak on topic with your moronic screen name then lol

[b00g13man]

Speak on topic with your moronic screen name then lol

Still waiting on the names of those "ton of HOFers" DLH stopped.....

Clueless nitwit.

[IronDanHamza]

Oscar fought at 147 in 2008. Just because he was faking KO's against Hopkins doesn't mean he wasn't willing to fight Floyd. Floyd was not chasing that fight AT ALL> Why speak on things that happened when you weren't even a boxing fan yet?

He fought at 147 I main 2008 after not fighting there for 7 years and was drained to death in the process.

You have yet to explain yourself as to how that fight was feasible in 2005. It was not.

The earliest time was 2007. 2006 would be pushing it because Oscar needed a tune up after taking 2005 off.

[LoadedWraps]

Maidana beat Floyd, that's why there had to be a rematch. Should of been at least a draw, that first fight was devastating.

Maidana is my favorite WW


But credit to Floyd for showing who's the better of the two in the rematch

That version of Maidana stops Thurman cold.

[Verbal Kint]

Maidana put up the most spirited effort but he didn't really come close to actually winning.

[LoadedWraps]

Maidana put up the most spirited effort but he didn't really come close to actually winning.

It was a draw, if we are going to keep it one hunnid like a c-note.

[Tony Trick-Pony]

honestly i'm not being biased or anything but i don't think he's ever legitimately lost a round.

No argument here.