FAO: Floyd Mayweather Jr. Supporters

[The Gambler1981]

hernandez? can you even list one credible win for him? and please dont say paez

Azumah Nelson

[IMDAZED]

didn't say raheem didn't win. so stfu already.

still good win for pac.

helped him win fighter of the decade. it is what it is.

What's a good win? Beating Raheem? Because that didn't happen. He fought the loser. You think it was a good win, I don't. You're starting to show your soreness a bit. I don't blame you.

[Left Hook Tua]

I know what you said -- show me where they had him #2 is what I'm saying.

ring magazine. google it

[Left Hook Tua]

What's a good win? Beating Raheem? Because that didn't happen. He fought the loser. You think it was a good win, I don't. You're starting to show your soreness a bit. I don't blame you.

not soreness.

tiredness.

going around in circles.

[The Big Dunn]

jmm for pac is not the same as jmm for floyd. that's why i don't compare it.

and i told you it's not about jmm nor do i care to make it about jmm.

it's about tough fights vs. great opp over dominating a lesser opp.

losing close fight to jmm is better than dominating david diaz.

you gotta take the pac-floyd comparisons out so you can be impartial.


use castillo. better win? tough fight vs castillo or dominating ndou?

of course castillo even though it was tougher.

ok. his is a somewhat different question than what you asked.

Regarding resume, a tough loss still takes away from a resume and a dominant win over a lesser fighter either keeps you in the same place or slightly elevates you.

A loss, except an outright robbery like sweet pea/Ramirez or Bradley/many, is always negative on a fighter's resume IMO.

[Left Hook Tua]

You now have forced me to agree with the mayweather supporters with this incendiary post.

bird > jordan

[Larry the boss]

5 days to go

[The Gambler1981]

ok. his is a somewhat different question than what you asked.

Regarding resume, a tough loss still takes away from a resume and a dominant win over a lesser fighter either keeps you in the same place or slightly elevates you.

A loss, except an outright robbery like sweet pea/Ramirez or Bradley/many, is always negative on a fighter's resume IMO.

A loss can be kind of neutral, Sanchez-Nelson but you have to be a crazy underdog and showed up in a big way against a big time player.

[bigjavi973]

let's do cotto 9 best opponents.

40 yr old serg with bad knees
the *** with a broken leg
the former flyweight who kicked his ass
the guy who made him take knees
same guy but with one eye
austin trout
joshua clottey
kelson pinto
ricardo torres

at least be real with cotto's list.... can you even make a real list for cotto?

[IMDAZED]

ring magazine. google it

I did. Didn't find it. Where did you?

BTW Ring Magazine -- you're go-to source for rankings -- has Mayweather rated way higher than Manny all-time. Guess they've closed this debate for you.