What is the most overrated win any active fighter has?

[FerFAL]

I think Matthysse is overrated here he went life and death with Molina jr who got completely outclassed by Micky Bey (definition of average) until he landed a miracle punch. If you can box a bit and have good chin you will beat lucas.

Yeah, problem with that is that reality doesnt agree with you: 36 wins (34 KOs) and 3 losses

[Dr Rumack]

I think Matthysse is overrated here he went life and death with Molina jr who got completely outclassed by Micky Bey (definition of average) until he landed a miracle punch. If you can box a bit and have good chin you will beat lucas.

Matthysse beat Judah and Alexander in the eyes of just about every observer, and knocked out Lamont Peterson. The only other fighter who handled Peterson easily was Timothy Bradley. Those are all fighters who were at or near the top of 140 in the last few years.

[zmm001]

Yeah, problem with that is that reality doesnt agree with you: 36 wins (34 KOs) and 3 losses

soon to be 4 losses when provo sparks him

[JStill Unbiased]

most of wards wins

Well, explain how?

[JStill Unbiased]

i'm surprised there has only been one mention of danny over lucas i think that win is massively overblown.

Are you a Lucas fan, and did you pick Lucas to win the fight?

[JStill Unbiased]

Manny v. Bradley (the most overrated fighter of this era)

I'd favor Bradley over Danny Garcia, Broner, maybe even Robert Guerrero. But Bradley gets beat by pretty much every body else at 147 and 154. Canelo, Cotto, Lara, Trout, Thurman, Maidana, Khan, K9 I mean seriously, who would pick Bradley to beat any of these guys?

[Dana White Sr]

Crawford vs Gamboa

Gamboa was 2 divisions removed from where he should be and still had a lot if success early on

I think Crawford is insanely overrated on this board. Hes supposed to be one of the top at 140 without even fighting there yet.

This is the best answer so far.

The rest of these bias and confused doofballs are talking nonsense posting, cotto-martinez, mayweather-corrales lol, ward-kessler and a whole bunch of silly bull****.

[Tay Roc]

Danny over Matthysse.

Kovalev over Hopkins.

Stevenson over Dawson.

Mayweather over Canelo.

Cotto over Martinez.

[Juof]

Solid pick but a lot of people give cotto very little credit for that win.

Alot of people thought martinez was gunna do him.

[////]

Cotto vs Martinez, Cotto fans pretended they were dumb deaf and blind and that Cotto just "made history against all odds". Everyone else was ashamed the commission allowed Martinez to fight.