What is the most overrated win any active fighter has?

[zmm001]

By this I mean which win do people talk about to boost a fighters standing that you don't think is that impressive now looking at the circumstances. Robberies don't count unless most people actually use that fight as an argument for how good a fighter is. eg hardly anyone uses bradley win over pac so it is not overrated.


p.s can we try not to make this a war between manny and floyd fans calling all their wins overrated.

[Daddy T]

cotto over martinez ... martinez was a shell

[zmm001]

cotto over martinez ... martinez was a shell

Solid pick but a lot of people give cotto very little credit for that win.

[Ahmed_Ismail]

Manny Pacquiao vs Oscar dela Hoya & Chris Algieri
Brandon Rios vs Mike Alvardo 3
Amir Khan vs Devon Alexander

[General STRUGG]

Floyd vs Oscar.
floyd vs Mosley
Floyd vs genaro hernandez
Floyd vs chico coralles

[DoubleMM]

pacquiao vs bradley

bradley is so overrated its crazy

the dude was crushed by ruslan and had a draw with diego chavez

and the marquez fight was close

I know he's overrated because there are idiots on here who claim marquez was schooled. bradley looked like pure **** vs marquez and it was a close fight.

[Ahmed_Ismail]

Floyd vs Oscar.
floyd vs Mosley
Floyd vs genaro hernandez
Floyd vs chico coralles

Obviously a Mayweather hater

[trixx12]

Danny gift Garcia vs Mathysse

[Pac=Duran]

I would say Mayweather vs Canelo

Canelo is one of the best boilers in boxing but the thing is that he is a pretty ordinary fighter, nothing special about him. In the words of Roger Mayweather "Sometime's you have to create an opponent"

Also Stevenson vs Chad Dawson. Seems like Dawson lost interest after his buffoonish choice of calling Ward out at 168. Feather fisted Ward took his soul lol

[Dr Rumack]

Adonis Stevenson over Chad Dawson perhaps.

Amir Khan over Maidana would be up there too. Good win, but Khan has been rated too highly off the back of it ever since.