Lets Make it Official....Castillo Vs Mayweather....Who won? (Throwback Edition)

[punchr]

Castillo beat him up.

[boliodogs]

It was close but I thought Castillo won. Castillo threw more punches and landed more punches and took the fight to Mayweather in enough rounds to win the fight. Simple as that.

[ModernTalking]

Floyd won, he got hits more.

[extracurRICular]

Sorry Ric. The topic of this thread shows up twice a month

Not with a poll AAAAAAAAAAAAND the "official" mark.......

oh yeah........Don't Jimmy Me Jewlz............

[Ahmed_Ismail]

It was close but I thought Castillo won. Castillo threw more punches and landed more punches and took the fight to Mayweather in enough rounds to win the fight. Simple as that.

Yeah he threw and landed more in total, but professional boxing is not judged based on the total number of punches landed throughout the whole fight, professional boxing is scored round by round. Fact is Castillo got off to a very slow start and it cost him the first 5 rounds, there's no way u can tell me that he won any of these rounds, 9 and 10 were definitely Mayweather rounds and the rest either Castillo won or were even. Please pretty please watch this fight on mute! If the commentators were on Mayweather's side most people would have said Floyd won the fight.
Props for Floyd for giving the guy an immediate rematch to erase any doubts and he did that by shutting Castillo out in the rematch, only if fighters today "cough Gacia cough" would learn from that.

[Beercules]

Castillo WOOPED his ass.

[IronDanHamza]

Close fight that could have gone either way.

Haven't seen a thread like this before.

[-Kev-]

Oh god...14 years of "The thread of all threads, the official, the last one, the big one...Mayweather vs Castillo...who really won???"

Can admins please just sticky one of the 167 Mayweather vs Castillo threads already?

[-Kev-]

It was close but I thought Castillo won. Castillo threw more punches and landed more punches and took the fight to Mayweather in enough rounds to win the fight. Simple as that.

Dawson threw more and landed more punches vs Pascal. Dawson got robbed.

[extracurRICular]

Oh god...14 years of "The thread of all threads, the official, the last one, the big one...Mayweather vs Castillo...who really won???"

Can admins please just sticky one of the 167 Mayweather vs Castillo threads already?

Yeah.........sticky these............................



















































































































THESE NUUUUUUUUUUUTZZZZZZZZZZZ......