Thurman win vs Guerrero better than Floyds

[KayDub]

Your whole entire argument was based on punches landed, which is essentially the accuracy of a fighter's onslaught. It sure as hell matters lol, especially if Robert threw almost 100 punches more against Floyd and only managed to land around 14 more overall then against Thurman. Keith was more offensive minded as well and executed a completely different gameplan than Floyd but Floyd dominated Guerrero and only had to resort to his defensive maneuvers.

Thurman may have more power than Floyd but they both fight completely different. They may have won their fights against Guerrero but went about it two completely different ways and at the end of it all, Floyd may have not looked as impressive because of his defensive style, but he beat Guerrero more soundly and with no troubles whatsoever.

I didn't say Floyd didn't win the fight soundly, just that Thurman did it better. Sure, better could be subjective.

You're not making sense with your correlation to accuracy. He landed more, THAT is what matters.

[LinealChampion]

Damn Floyd always finishes last.

Pacquiao's Mosley, Hatton, Delahoya win was better than Floyds.

Margarito's, Cotto win was better than Floyds.

Luiz Collazos, Ortiz win was better than Floyds.

It just never ends with you guys.

[SeekDaGreat]

Damn Floyd always finishes last.

Pacquiao's Mosley, Hatton, Delahoya win was better than Floyds.

Margarito's, Cotto win was better than Floyds.

Luiz Collazos, Ortiz win was better than Floyds.

It just never ends with you guys.

Well, he's boring. That's the price you pay when you don't fight to entertain the fans. You finish last.

If Floyd had a career full of Maidana 1 type fights I bet you the rhetoric would be different. Plain and simple.

[Rath]

Damn Floyd always finishes last.

Pacquiao's Mosley, Hatton, Delahoya win was better than Floyds.

Margarito's, Cotto win was better than Floyds.

Luiz Collazos, Ortiz win was better than Floyds.

It just never ends with you guys.

they forgot one fight. nobody has ever beaten josie harris better than Floyd

[Rath]

Well, he's boring. That's the price you pay when you don't fight to entertain the fans. You finish last.

If Floyd had a career full of Maidana 1 type fights I bet you the rhetoric would be different. Plain and simple.

instead we have a career full of Maidana 2 with lots of 12th round to booth

[KayDub]

Damn Floyd always finishes last.

Pacquiao's Mosley, Hatton, Delahoya win was better than Floyds.

Margarito's, Cotto win was better than Floyds.

Luiz Collazos, Ortiz win was better than Floyds.

It just never ends with you guys.

Whoa whoa whoa, this is not a thread to hate on Floyd. This is just a thread highlighting how good Thurman really is and how good he is going to become on his current trajectory.

I don't want this thread to be about Floyd, I was just using him as a measuring stick considering he's in the top 2 of this era (May 2nd proves who is #1 and #2).

[LinealChampion]

they forgot one fight. nobody has ever beaten josie harris better than Floyd

lol, good point.

[LinealChampion]

Well, he's boring. That's the price you pay when you don't fight to entertain the fans. You finish last.

If Floyd had a career full of Maidana 1 type fights I bet you the rhetoric would be different. Plain and simple.

Well, we are comparing a counter puncher to a supposed "one time" Ko Puncher.

So I would think the counter puncher would be boring.

[Carpe Diem]

You guys are so predictable.

[mathed]

Floyd's power shots don't mean ****. Guerrero kept coming forward against Floyd. Keith's power shots stopped Guerrero in his tracks and made him sit back and think.

Yet he finished the fight and won a few rounds by forcing Thurman against the ropes. Thurman was also a middleweight on fight night as well.