This is how the fight would play out.
I think it'd be a close fight. First 2 rounds go either way. 3rd round, Cotto scores a knockdown.
4th round- Cotto edges out the round while JMM recovers.
5th round- swing round, could go either way
6th round- goes to JMM
7th round- Cotto takes it
8th round- Cotto takes it
Rounds 9, 10, 11, goes to JMM
Round 12- swing round
Judges reward Cotto with a majority decision win...One judge scores it a draw. The other 2 score it for Cotto. 114-113, 115-112
JMM storms out of the ring in protest and then tells reporters, he believes he won the fight.
Comment