h2h who would have won. Toney vs Hopkins

[Jc8804]

this is probably 1 of 4 fights i never got to see but wish we could have.
thats a purists fight for the ages imo.

Who wins in your opinion

[John Locke]

Toney would win clearly

[Jc8804]

James is so crafty and tough.

You got b hop whonis also crafty but woyld be forced to lead.

[djtmal]

depends imo...

if its the toney that fought jones, hopkins

if its the toney that was ready for barkley, toney...

depends on which toney shows up imo...

[IMDAZED]

When they were discussing back it in 2003 I think Toney would've massacred him.

[Jc8804]

Hops fall in rt hand would be met with a sharpe ass rt uppercut.imo toney has a top 5 alltime inside fight game.

Hop has a good jab but toneys straight rt counter is
vicious to overcome

[gmc_rfc_06]

Toney, easily.

B-Hop is an ATG, but James Toney was a special talent. He would have countered Bernard and generally dominated at close quarters.

Toney via wide UD.

[jas]

Hopkins wins a UD . Uses movement and potshots.

[Hype job]

[The Big Dunn]

I'll take Toney by UD, maybe 8-4.