Comments Thread For: Khan: Brook is A lot Slower Than Devon, I'd School Him!

[Dirk Diggler UK]

I didn't say 'one shot', you've just added that. I don't agree about Gracia, but even if that were correct Garcia KO'd Khan so you're not making a point.

Im making the point that Brook isn't the most powerful puncher he's faced and I didn't just name Garcia who clearly does hit harder than Brook

[wence]

danny garcia was slow too doe

[Wicky]

Im making the point that Brook isn't the most powerful puncher he's faced and I didn't just name Garcia who clearly does hit harder than Brook

You're not making it very well. You're saying Garcia punches "far harder". I disagree.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

You're not making it very well. You're saying Garcia punches "far harder". I disagree.

I'm not making it very well? From the guy whose only counter argument is "I disagree"

[Wicky]

I'm not making it very well? From the guy whose only counter argument is "I disagree"

Everything you say is subjective. That's the only argument required.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Everything you say is subjective. That's the only argument required.

As is what you're saying. The difference is I'm using reasoning and logic to back up my points.

What basis do you use to say Brook is a harder puncher than Garcia or Maidana for instance?

[tokon]

Khan has a good chance of beating brook, but why talk nonsense?

He said before brook fought porter that he'd fight him if he won, and he said after the fight: "let's make the fight happen man".

It honestly sounds to me like he's ducking now. I don't think he is but he makes it sound like it. If he doesn't get may/PAC next then there's no excuse for not fighting brook IMO.

Unless he gets Garcia or Bradley.

khan isnt getting mayweather in may.

he isnt getting pac, bradley or garcia either.

the big money - and a title to get him to floyd - is against brook.

is he ducking him?!

[Wicky]

As is what you're saying. The difference is I'm using reasoning and logic to back up my points.

What basis do you use to say Brook is a harder puncher than Garcia or Maidana for instance?

Have an opinion. Don't mistake it for logic.

Based on:

• Brook's ability to manhandle Porter.
• Various feedback from old opponents.
• Many sports commentators who often say the same thing.

Maidana & Garcia were both at 140. Their power may carry over to 147 maybe not. Maidana has lost 3 out of 7 fights at the higher weight. Kell's a natural Welter and big for the division. That alone gives him a power advantage IMO.

[Wuckoo]

Have an opinion. Don't mistake it for logic.

Based on:

• Brook's ability to manhandle Porter.
• Various feedback from old opponents.
• Many sports commentators who often say the same thing.

Maidana & Garcia were both at 140. Their power may carry over to 147 maybe not. Maidana has lost 3 out of 7 fights at the higher weight. Kell's a natural Welter and big for the division. That alone gives him a power advantage IMO.

I second that. Ricky Hatton once sparred with kell and said he hit pretty hard

[Corelone]

I kind of agree with Khan, that Kell needs at least one tune up before such a fight. Too many arguments for it. A long lay off, a bad injury, hard partying (he did win a championship). Someone not too dangerous, but give a good work out, like Paulie.