Who was more impressive against Alexander: Khan or Porter?

[ShoulderRoll]

I thought both guys looked great but in different ways. Amir flashed great speed and boxing ability while Porter was more physically punishing.

[bojangles1987]

Khan. Porter mugged him, Khan plain beat his ass.

[yoz]

Khan. Porter mugged him, Khan plain beat his ass.

This ^^^^^^^^.

[brettWall]

Porter is a plain brawler. It works for him, though.

[torosboxing75]

Khan. Porter mugged him, Khan plain beat his ass.

This is similar to my thoughts ^^^^^^^^^^^^

[gmc_rfc_06]

One schooled him and the other bullied him, Whatever you prefer.

[ShoulderRoll]

The whipping that Kell Brook gave him has taken some of the shine off Porter. But people were raving about him immediately after the Devon fight just like they are praising Khan today.

[Heavyfist]

I think its obviously Khan, because he beat Alexander at his own game, the boxing game.

Porter used his size, rather than any skills. And remember Floyd called Alexander his heir. That is the level of Alexanders skill. Khan still schooled him.

[Beercules]

I was at the Porter Alexander fight, I was jumping out of my seat for that ass wooping


As others have said, both beat Devon up, different ways.