How would gennedy golovkin do against these guys?

[Half step]

Short answer is that its way too early to tell. I like God of War as much as the next guy but he hasn't had the chance to show his true level of talent against a top level fighter.

Agreed time will tell

[tjones1989]

Trinidad would get pasted around the ring cus he has no business at 160. GGG would woop dat ass.
Toney would get his ass wooped have you seen that guy, his boobs are bigger than my ***ing head. GGG would woop dat ass.
Mike McCallum, who is that? I bet nobody here who that is lol. He would get his ass wooped to. GGG with another ass woopin!
Julian Jackson, hmm that's a hard one. I'd say this would be a war, could go either way.
Pazienza, who the *** is this. But he's pretty big so maybe he'd have a chance. But he'd get that ass beat regardless. Pizzazenza would get baked lololol.
Kessler, to lazy to look him up but he'd that ass beat to.
Froch would beat GGG's ass. To big, to skilled.
Chavez Jr would get his ass beat to. He's to busy smoking weed and not making weight to be a threat to GGG. Did you see him get beat by Martinez by shutout. He shouldnt be on the list.
Winky would win by decision, GGG ain't that good.
Tommy Hearns, sers bro? Tommy Hearns would cut GGG up and slice him a new one. Why is he even on here.
Jake Lamotta? lol, Lamotta would tenderize GGG. This one is obvious.
Martinez would easily beat GGG, easily.
This is getting ridiculous, Roy jones would whoop him!! And don't care about the rest.

[MDPopescu]

Trinidad that fought hopkins at 160.
Toney who fought Roy at 160
Mike McCallum at 160
Julian Jackson who fought Gman at 160
Pazienza who fought Roy at 168
Kessler who beat froch at 168
Froch who ko bute at 168
Chavez jr who fought Andy lee at 160
Winky who fought Trinidad at 160(or was that 154?)
Past prime tommy hearns at 160
Jake lamotta at 160
Martinez who beat Chavez jr at 160
Hopkins who lost to Taylor 1
Roy who was scary at 160
Pavlik who ko Taylor at 160
Taylor who beat hopkins at 160

I think Roy,toney,McCallum ,lamotta,martinez(bad style matchup for ggg),and Hopkins beat him
Maybe Trinidad and froch
The rest are tough to call but they prob lose

Did you forget Harry Greb and Sugar Ray Robinson? What a shame!.

[GOD-FR33]

First of all....

First of all, how old are you? Second of all, James "Lights Out" Toney would beat GGG's ass!!!!!!! You do not know anything about "prime" Toney, obviously. A motivated primed JT was poison, kid. Triple GGG has much to prove still B4 you go talking that stuff. Toney wasn't always "fat" and a heavyweight.

[Half step]

Did you forget Harry Greb and Sugar Ray Robinson? What a shame!.

No I didn't put them on the list because its implied ggg would lose to both even though prime ray was 147

[$Bullsfam$]

He loses wide decisions to Toney, Hopkins, Roy, Winky, Taylor, and Martinez.

Loses close wars to McCallum, Trinidad, Kessler, Trinidad, Froch, and Jake Lamott a

Julian Jackson, Past prime Hearns, and Pavlik are all pick em fights. I could any of these men either getting the KO or getting KO'd.

Paz and Chavez I'm sure he would beat but this is all on what I've seen from him. He needs a step up in competition to really seriously gauge where he's at amongst these guys.

[soul_survivor]

Maaaaaaaaaan, the fanboyism here is wild, people picking GGG against some genuinely great fighters...shiiiiit.

Truth be told, it's incredibly hard to say how GGG is right now, he has had two steps up in class thus far, Macklin and Geale, both were dispatched easily and were at the time of the beating, top 10 level middleweights but in the grand scheme of things, neither of those fighters are great or even outstanding middleweights.

GGG, to no fault of his own missed out on prime Pavlik, Taylor, Williams and Martinez, you could possibly add Winky to that generation of middleweights. The division is in a transitional phase right now and there really aren't any great fighters around at the moment.

Going off of what I've seen so far of him, he'd have some good fights but I just don't think he beats the upper echelon of the division over the last 20 years.

[Half step]

[QUOTE=tjones1989;14939968]Trinidad would get pasted around the ring cus he has no business at 160. GGG would woop dat ass.
Toney would get his ass wooped have you seen that guy, his boobs are bigger than my ***ing head. GGG would woop dat ass.
Mike McCallum, who is that? I bet nobody here who that is lol. He would get his ass wooped to. GGG with another ass woopin!
Julian Jackson, hmm that's a hard one. I'd say this would be a war, could go either way.
Pazienza, who the *** is this. But he's pretty big so maybe he'd have a chance. But he'd get that ass beat regardless. Pizzazenza would get baked lololol.
Kessler, to lazy to look him up but he'd that ass beat to.
Froch would beat GGG's ass. To big, to skilled.
Chavez Jr would get his ass beat to. He's to busy smoking weed and not making weight to be a threat to GGG. Did you see him get beat by Martinez by shutout. He shouldnt be on the list.
Winky would win by decision, GGG ain't that good.
Tommy Hearns, sers bro? Tommy Hearns would cut GGG up and slice him a new one. Why is he even on here.
Jake Lamotta? lol, Lamotta would tenderize GGG. This one is obvious.
Martinez would easily beat GGG, easily.
This is getting ridiculous, Roy jones would whoop him!! And don't care about the rest.[/QUOTE

REPLY


Apparently you have limited boxing knowledge with some of these comments

Toney wasn't a fat slob at 160 he was a beast and has super slick defense and great power at 160 I favor him to beat ggg

McCallum was a top 5 154-160 guy and is underrated he had murderous body work and could really box well and was very durable it would be a 50/50 fight that would prob go distance

You give Julian Jackson a shot over McCallum ? Jackson had leaky D ,ok boxing and a weak chin . He's just remembered for his great power. Ggg has better fundamentals and would likely KO Jackson

Kessler was very good in his prime and is bigger than ggg also he's never been stopped even in 2 fights with froch toss up fight with ggg but slightly favor golovkin

Froch is bigger but to skilled?gtfoh froch has success mostly through war of attrition he comes toward getting hit often and beats u down. He's probably the crudest guy on the list along with lamotta. Anyway froch has a style all wrong for ggg he gets hit to much golovkin would prob KO Froch or beat him down over 12

[#1Assassin]

Trinidad that fought hopkins at 160.
Toney who fought Roy at 160
Mike McCallum at 160
Julian Jackson who fought Gman at 160
Pazienza who fought Roy at 168
Kessler who beat froch at 168
Froch who ko bute at 168
Chavez jr who fought Andy lee at 160
Winky who fought Trinidad at 160(or was that 154?)
Past prime tommy hearns at 160
Jake lamotta at 160
Martinez who beat Chavez jr at 160
Hopkins who lost to Taylor 1
Roy who was scary at 160
Pavlik who ko Taylor at 160
Taylor who beat hopkins at 160

I think Roy,toney,McCallum ,lamotta,martinez(bad style matchup for ggg),and Hopkins beat him
Maybe Trinidad and froch
The rest are tough to call but they prob lose

tito knocks him out
toney knocks him out
mccallum outpoints him or stops him late
jackson knocks him out
pazienza gets murdered
kessler gets murdered
froch outpoints him or stops him late
chavez gets knocked out
winky loses on points
tommy knocks him out
lamotta outpoints him or stops him late
martinez probably beats him on points, but might get caught and KO'd
hopkins outpoints him
roy outpoints him
pavlik gets knocked out
taylor gets murdered

6-10

considering his level of opposition i think i give him a lot of credit. one day he might be comparable to the likes of hopkins, RJJ, hearns, lamotta, mccallum etc. in fact i believe he will.

but as of now you cant give him more credit than this, his level of opposition simply doesnt allow it.

[The Surgeon]

Trinidad that fought hopkins at 160.
Toney who fought Roy at 160
Mike McCallum at 160
Julian Jackson who fought Gman at 160
Pazienza who fought Roy at 168
Kessler who beat froch at 168
Froch who ko bute at 168
Chavez jr who fought Andy lee at 160
Winky who fought Trinidad at 160(or was that 154?)
Past prime tommy hearns at 160
Jake lamotta at 160
Martinez who beat Chavez jr at 160
Hopkins who lost to Taylor 1
Roy who was scary at 160
Pavlik who ko Taylor at 160
Taylor who beat hopkins at 160
I think Roy,toney,McCallum ,lamotta,martinez(bad style matchup for ggg),and Hopkins beat him
Maybe Trinidad and froch
The rest are tough to call but they prob lose

Trinidad that fought hopkins at 160. GOLOVKIN KO
Toney who fought Roy at 160 TONEY LATE TKO
Mike McCallum at 160 MCCALLUM UD
Julian Jackson who fought Gman at 160 GOLOVKIN KO
Pazienza who fought Roy at 168 GOLOVKIN KO
Kessler who beat froch at 168 GOLOVKIN LATE TKO
Froch who ko bute at 168 GOLOVKIN UD
Chavez jr who fought Andy lee at 160 GOLOVKIN TKO
Winky who fought Trinidad at 160(or was that 154?) 154
Past prime tommy hearns at 160 GOLOVKIN KO
Jake lamotta at 160 LAMOTTA POINTS
Martinez who beat Chavez jr at 160 GOLOVKIN KO
Hopkins who lost to Taylor 1 GOLOVKIN SPLIT DECISION
Roy who was scary at 160 JONES TKO
Pavlik who ko Taylor at 160 hmm..GOLOVKIN KO
Taylor who beat hopkins at 160 GOLOVKIN KO