Worst decision/robbery/scorecard(s) in the last 2 years?

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • 4Corners
    Nothing But Sunshine
    Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
    • Jul 2011
    • 14441
    • 485
    • 83
    • 25,167

    #11
    I don't think Garcia-Herrera deserves to be mentioned with Rios-Abril, Cloud-Campillo, Pac-Bradley 1, Beltran-Burns, etc.

    Garcia actually won 4-5 rounds IMO. He lost the fight, but he won some rounds. Garcia actually landed the same or more punches than Herrera in 6 rounds, and landed more power punches than Herrera in 11 rounds.

    I still felt Herrera won, controlled more rounds using his jab. But Garcia won his fair share of rounds. I don't even think that was a "robbery". Robbery is a strong word, thrown around too much on here.

    Comment

    • IronDanHamza
      BoxingScene Icon
      Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
      • Oct 2009
      • 49583
      • 5,045
      • 270
      • 104,043

      #12
      Originally posted by 4Corners
      I don't think Garcia-Herrera deserves to be mentioned with Rios-Abril, Cloud-Campillo, Pac-Bradley 1, Beltran-Burns, etc.

      Garcia actually won 4-5 rounds IMO. He lost the fight, but he won some rounds. Garcia actually landed the same or more punches than Herrera in 6 rounds, and landed more power punches than Herrera in 11 rounds.

      I still felt Herrera won, controlled more rounds using his jab. But Garcia won his fair share of rounds. I don't even think that was a "robbery". Robbery is a strong word, thrown around too much on here.
      Of course it wasn't a robbery. Most of the rounds were close so that alone makes it not a robbery.

      What kind of robbery has 30% of the press row not scoring it for the person who was apparently robbed?

      Pretty obvious close fight. But of course that means ROBBERY! Biggest robbery EVER in HISTORY

      Comment

      • 4Corners
        Nothing But Sunshine
        Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
        • Jul 2011
        • 14441
        • 485
        • 83
        • 25,167

        #13
        Originally posted by IronDanHamza
        Of course it wasn't a robbery. Most of the rounds were close so that alone makes it not a robbery.

        What kind of robbery has 30% of the press row not scoring it for the person who was apparently robbed?

        Pretty obvious close fight. But of course that means ROBBERY! Biggest robbery EVER in HISTORY
        I think I scored it 7-5 Herrera. I think the majority on here, who were all over Lucas' jock, were so happy to see Garcia basically lose a fight, that they screamed worst robbery ever. Even though in reality, you could make a case as strong as 8-4 Herrera or that it was as close as a draw.

        I could see maybe a draw if you favored everything for Garcia, but no wider than 8-4 Herrera favoring everything for him. I find it absurd people were saying Herrera won 10-2/9-3. That's as ridiculous as saying Danny won 8-4.

        I don't know if I could go as far as saying Danny won the fight though. But it certainly wasn't a robbery. It was a close fight that should have gone Herrera's way IMO.

        Comment

        • IronDanHamza
          BoxingScene Icon
          Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
          • Oct 2009
          • 49583
          • 5,045
          • 270
          • 104,043

          #14
          Originally posted by 4Corners
          I think I scored it 7-5 Herrera. I think the majority on here, who were all over Lucas' jock, were so happy to see Garcia basically lose a fight, that they screamed worst robbery ever. Even though in reality, you could make a case as strong as 8-4 Herrera or that it was as close as a draw.

          I could see maybe a draw if you favored everything for Garcia, but no wider than 8-4 Herrera favoring everything for him. I find it absurd people were saying Herrera won 10-2/9-3. That's as ridiculous as saying Danny won 8-4.

          I don't know if I could go as far as saying Danny won the fight though. But it certainly wasn't a robbery. It was a close fight that should have gone Herrera's way IMO.
          I scored it for Garcia. Just edging it by a point.

          I can understand why more thought Herrera won but the fight was obviously close.

          Those other fights mentioned where not close and the press row scores showed that.

          Comment

          • 4Corners
            Nothing But Sunshine
            Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
            • Jul 2011
            • 14441
            • 485
            • 83
            • 25,167

            #15
            Originally posted by IronDanHamza
            I scored it for Garcia. Just edging it by a point.

            I can understand why more thought Herrera won but the fight was obviously close.

            Those other fights mentioned where not close and the press row scores showed that.
            That fight was a clear case of 95% of this place hating Garcia and how he beat the flavor of the month who'll kill anyone in the history of the world Lucas Matthysse. People hated Garcia, so any close rounds they paid attention only to what Herrera did, and didn't see Garcia actually was landing some power shots throughout the fight.

            Like I said....I scored it for Herrera, but I wouldn't cry robbery that Danny won. I would say it's a decision I didn't agree with, but there was no "schooling" going on.

            Comment

            • Build That Wall
              TRUMP 2024
              Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
              • May 2012
              • 18987
              • 679
              • 868
              • 78,835

              #16
              Lara vs Alvarez

              Rios vs Abril

              Comment

              • 4Corners
                Nothing But Sunshine
                Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                • Jul 2011
                • 14441
                • 485
                • 83
                • 25,167

                #17
                Canelo vs Lara wasn't even remotely close to a robbery....the right guy won.

                LIke 40% of the press scores for Canelo, 30% Lara, and 30% draw or something.

                C'mon man.

                Comment

                • Luilun
                  Undisputed Champion
                  Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                  • Dec 2010
                  • 12457
                  • 555
                  • 94
                  • 58,436

                  #18
                  Originally posted by SlySlickSmooth
                  Garcia-Herrera and Rios-Abril would belong up there.

                  What's the worst fight outcome we've had in the last two years?
                  Pacquaio vs Bradley Mayweather vs Madaina

                  Comment

                  • Jbose7
                    Contender
                    • Dec 2013
                    • 146
                    • 7
                    • 0
                    • 6,205

                    #19
                    I don't think Pac- Bradley was a robbery....a robbery is when you clearly know the guy won 8 out of 12 rounds and they were not swing rounds....in Pac-Bradley their were too many swing rounds which was z Manny's fault cause he choose to fight for 30 seconds a round. Same thing Lara did except he threw more punches that would miss and Bradley was active

                    Comment

                    • BOXEO _
                      Banned
                      Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                      • Feb 2014
                      • 14407
                      • 597
                      • 254
                      • 33,750

                      #20
                      Originally posted by Box-Office
                      Pacquiao-Bradley 1.

                      Rios-Abril.

                      Herrera-Garcia.

                      Cloud-Campillo.

                      Beltran Burns.

                      Good ones...

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      TOP