Is Nonito a Hall of Famer or ATG?

[CatchAndShoot]

Yes, you can consider him HOF worthy. Him being Filipino only helps. He's done good for the Filipino community and one of their top stars.

[jas]

Neither.......

[CatchAndShoot]

Getting into the boxing HOF is like getting into the WWE HOF. He'll get in, no doubt. He's got the Arum connection. He'll get in.

[Beercules]

No sir. Neither.

[The Big Dunn]

right now, not a HOF'er or ATG. He has a lot left and should get some really good opponents as he goes up and if he wins he will surely be a HOF'er.

[Dodger07]

I think hes accomplished enough and has beaten just enough good fighters to warrant the hall of fame, and he still has time to continue building his resume.

[Fetta]

No and no way in hell

[JmH Reborn]

Hmmm - I haven't really thought about Donaire in a HoF sense - let alone as an ATG. My first inclination is to say 'no' on both fronts - but quickly looking at his resume, it's borderline HoF.

He's only 29, so there are a few years to make something happen. I just think he might no longer be in his prime and has peaked as a fighter. From a confidence standpoint - he might be a lil' shot.

[dante_1]

He's HOF, but not ATG.

[Dodger07]

Hmmm - I haven't really thought about Donaire in a HoF sense - let alone as an ATG. My first inclination is to say 'no' on both fronts - but quickly looking at his resume, it's borderline HoF.

He's only 29, so there are a few years to make something happen. I just think he might no longer be in his prime and has peaked as a fighter. From a confidence standpoint - he might be a lil' shot.

I agree that hes borderline atm. He does have plenty of time to get some more big wins, but he does seem to have left his best days behind him already.