Is Nonito a Hall of Famer or ATG?

[Dodger07]

Hard-hitting puncher, possibly best left hook of his time.

4 division champ (not including interim belts)

Best wins against:
Nishioka
Montiel
Darchinyan

Other notable wins include:
Vetyeka
Arce
Vazquez Jr.
Mathebula
Narvaez
Tyson Marquez
Mthalane
Sydorenko

Does have bad loss to Rigo, but most recognize him as one of the best and most skilled fighters P4P along with Floyd and Ward.

Can Donaire be considered an all-time great, and does he deserve to be in the hall of fame?

[DeadLikeMe]

HOF, maybe. ATG? Maybe a Top 1,000 ATG.

[IMDAZED]

At this point I'm not sure he's either.

[SeekDaGreat]

No and no.

[AKAcronym]

I don't think so.

[soul_survivor]

HOFer imo, he has a heck of a resume and wins over top opponents and in most cases, when he was primed, he didn't just win, he destroyed.

An ATG? No...not yet.

[Dodger07]

If he were to fight and beat fighters such as Lomachenko, Gradovich, Jhonny Gonzalez or Nicholas Walters to unify would that help his cause? Or moving up to 130 and winning another title in another division

[Public_Enemy]

When it's all said and done, he'll be a hall of famer. Donaire's resume is already really good and he'll add some more good names to it before he's retired. I do believe he has peaked as a fighter already. I can't see him being considered an ATG.

[-Antonio-]

He will undoubtedly make the HOF. Who cares about his loss to Rigo? Rigo is a great fighter. Donaire might be one of the most devastating Flyweights ever. He was a HOF before the Vetyeka win. That pretty much sealed it.

[Divine Hammer]

he will never be hof or atg. he is a hype job. forget about him please.

gary russell jr >>>>>>> donaire