Calzaghe is definetly an all time great.

[toooooool]

Calzaghe had the perfect style that beats all other styles...he was the perfect
fighter in many ways and I think it is terrific..His technique was fantastic and
I loved how he bedeviled and dumbfounded great champions over and over
again to the point of embarrassment..No other fighter has ever fought like him;
Overwhelming opponents with rapid fire arm punches and super endurance.
Apparently this is the magic formula to victory and greatness.And for those
that say "Well,he beat an old Jones etc"....that is bologna.Calzaghe would
have been hell for anyone at any time.

[Rahat]

im british and he only beat 2 good fighters which were hopkins and jones i think he was really good but sadly fought 2 little in america.

[Accountoffline]

Calzaghe isnt ATG mate, never will be

[GhostBlade]

Calzaghe and his father can say he is this and that but see what happens when you duck fighters in their prime and have a style that isn't too pleasing to boxing fans? When all is said and done they're the ones making the case that Calzaghe is an all-time great while boxing fans have long since forgotten about Calzaghe and most of the people that remember him are British.

[Tha_Greatest]

calzaghe had everything to be everything to be a all time great. the record is perfect great skills, beat the legendary hopkins but he retired too quikkly. thats my view

[artfuL_]

...and so is Sven Ottke.

[Russian Crushin]

...and so is Sven Ottke.

Chris john too

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

In what??

[komodo]

1st ballot HOF'er.....that kid did good.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Calzaghe and his father can say he is this and that but see what happens when you duck fighters in their prime and have a style that isn't too pleasing to boxing fans? When all is said and done they're the ones making the case that Calzaghe is an all-time great while boxing fans have long since forgotten about Calzaghe and most of the people that remember him are British.

That'll be why he was inducted into the International Boxing Hall of Fame last week then.