Is Floyd Mayweather The Best Ever (TBE)?

[Larry the boss]

No

just good

Beat prime Sergio Martinez, paul williams, or GGG, prime pac, then he will be great.

You need to fight the absolute most dangerous fighter around your weigh class in order to prove you are the best, do that enough times and you might actually be TBE

Ask every boxing fan out there who is the most dangerous fight for floyd right now.
****ing Ortiz, ****ing, guerro, ****ing maidana !!!!!!!!!! give me a ****ing break

If it is just good then why is he the only fighter to do it?

[RetroSpeed05]

As skillful as he is, he doesn't have that defining ATG win that most historians look for when when ranking a fighter high.

Lets look at his best wins from each division

130
Genaro Hernandez ( Lineal)
Angel Manfredy
Gregorio Vargas
Diego Corrales
Carlos Hernandez
Jesus Chavez

135
Jose Luis Castillo ( Lineal)

Great start so far in his career, but at 140 he really was slacking here, regardless if fighters where ducking him or not you could only be judged whats on paper.

140
Gatti

At 147 i didn't think his resume is bad at all its great but not ATG status and some have asterisks.

Zab Judah (ibf title)
Carlos Baldomir ( Lineal)
Ricky Hatton (Moves up from 140, although have no problem with this since Hatton didn't want to fight Floyd at 140)
Marquez (moves up 2 weight classes)
Victor Ortiz (At the time was rated the #3 WW behind only Floyd & Pac)
Shane Mosley (Regains back his Lineal status)

154

Oscar De La Hoya
Miguel Cotto
Canelo ( Lineal)

Great career, could have been better, great skill but no ATG resume to be called TBE.

[carts]

depends n waht TBE he is talking about? but i know he is TBE in ducking quack quack lol

[TBear]

Not top 10 all time.

[Kuyukut]

no cherry picker can claim the title of tbe, never.

[110110110]

If it is just good then why is he the only fighter to do it?

?

Read my post again, if you have a normal functioning brain, then your question will be answered.

Besides that, your point is weak at best

Look at Julio César Chávez Sr he was 89-0 before loosing the first time.
Sugar Ray Robinson went undefeated in 91 straight fights, just to name a few.

Lest see if little floyd goes undefeated in his next 45 fights

Booom

[Larry the boss]

Not top 10 all time.

Who is on your top 10 list?

[way2strong]

So why wasn't he proclaimed the fighter of the decade? Damm Larry if your really a man why won't you realize we don't talk **** about him for no reason who the *** else has ever said "my health comes first" "belt's don't define me he can have it" just so he could avoid one midget fighter..When the cold war ends and mayweather goes on to do his own UFC type company will you still support him? ..He want's to fight in a fish tank where he can pick and choose open your eyes...This is why the TBE crap is a joke his resume is a joke

answer this larry

[Larry the boss]

?

Read my post again, if you have a normal functioning brain, then your question will be answered.

I read your post 3 times..now tell me who else has gone 46-0, won 10 world titles in 5 divisions while winning 4 lineal titles and being 24-0 in title fights

[110110110]

I read your post 3 times..now tell me who else has gone 46-0, won 10 world titles in 5 divisions while winning 4 lineal titles and being 24-0 in title fights

Your point is weak at best

Look at Julio César Chávez Sr he was 89-0 before loosing the first time.
Sugar Ray Robinson went undefeated in 91 straight fights, just to name a few.

Lest see if little floyd goes undefeated in his next 45 fights