Is Floyd So Great That A Close Fight = A Lost?

[SoulByThePound]

Na U biased, When floyd lands a bunch you probably see Miadana glow and watch the doves fly away. Meanwhile when Midana lands you're busy admiring something having to do with Floyd.


Silly reds, when will they learn?

Your the last person on here to call anyone bias!

[12TRIBEsRiSe]

So you use a shot cotto and a guy who isn't even a top 5 welterweight to prove these points lol.

no matter what is said you all will have a childish comeback... thing is you all hold this dude to such a high standard its insane, he cant have a tough fight, cant age, cant bleed in a boxing match, cant get hit etc

[MindBat]

Who has he fought. Canelo who has he beaten. I've never rated him, very slow mechanical. Shot cotto gave him a fight, so did a shot Hoya. Hatton? Ortiz? How is he considered among the greatest ever.

All of those guys had title belts and were coming off big wins.

Time to change that Hater Juice flavor.

.

[fcastro1]

All of those guys had title belts and were coming off big wins.

Time to change that Hater Juice flavor.

.

Hardly the resume of the greatest. What a joke. Might as well call joe calzaghe the goat. He's undefeated.

[Calabis]

I said that all night last night. These people are biased , hateful ******s who don't know shyt about boxing.

Oscar wins 4 rounds= Oscar won on NSB

Cotto wins 4 rounds= Cotto won on NSB

Maidana wins 4 rounds = Maidana wins on NSB

Rinse and repeat with these casual boxing fans.

Yeah I agree although I gave Maidana 5 rounds....what's worse is their hero actually had a 4 fight war with Marquez all much closer fights yet somehow they saw dominance.

[01samuelc]

no matter what is said you all will have a childish comeback... thing is you all hold this dude to such a high standard its insane, he cant have a tough fight, cant age, cant bleed in a boxing match, cant get hit etc

No i just simply see through his branding and business models. Fact is floyd hasn't looked spectacular against the few decent fighters he fought imo and ducked the rest. Which leads me to believe his actual value is much lower than his perceived value.

[01samuelc]

Yeah I agree although I gave Maidana 5 rounds....what's worse is their hero actually had a 4 fight war with Marquez all much closer fights yet somehow they saw dominance.

Their 'hero' fought most of the fighters he was meant to. Based on last nights events i guess its safe to safe there is a high probability floyd would not be undefeated if he did the same

[Calabis]

Hardly the resume of the greatest. What a joke. Might as well call joe calzaghe the goat. He's undefeated.

Its also a harder era to make fights due to promotional companies not working together. Now include the numerous belts, etc. This is not the Ali era. Hard to compare Floyd to greats from the past. But he is the GOAT of his era, deal with it.

[johnm is...]

still doesn't change the fact that mayweather fought a close fight against a guy who wasn't top ten p4p, wasn't in the top 5 at ww and is a crude slow brawler, and whose only stand out wins are beating a hype job (broner) and a mental midget (ortiz).........

kind of sad for a supposed #1 best p4p fighter and someone who proclaims himself to be the best ever...wouldn't u agree?

Still doesn't change the fact that you just pulled a number out of thin air, which was my original point.

Throw those excuses elsewhere.

[Calabis]

Their 'hero' fought most of the fighters he was meant to. Based on last nights events i guess its safe to safe there is a high probability floyd would not be undefeated if he did the same

Yawn...I mostly read this board...but they went from him being scared of Mosley, and after he beat him, did he get credit nope...not here they had to move the goalpost, Mosley was now old and crusty...their hero beats him later and more washed up and it was a beating of a great fighter. Then he was scared of Canelo, no way would he fight him....he does and wins easily....goalpost time Canelo now sucks and is somehow worse than Rios......now he fights a guy who weighed 20lbs and was able to push Floyd around...but didnt land anything great...close fight but Floyd won....now all of a sudden Maidana is a piece of **** and sucks...yet their hero beats a guy he already beat and lost 3 of his last 4 fights yet that dude is Ali on this board.

I appreciate Manny and Floyd the are ATG they have slipped off yet still are beating everyone. I just dont like Pacs fans sorry