should pac be p4p # 1?

[straightleft]

We are discussing recent opponents of both Mayweather and Pacquiao. You said JMM and Bradley are better and would beat any of Mayweathers. I disagree because Canelo would beat both at 152. Which is the weight Mayweather fought him at, he didn't fight him at the mythical P4P weight class.

Saying Canelo would beat JMM and Bradley is just like both will Canelo at 146 but this fantasy and Floyd wins all in fantasy.

[assiong]

Actually in the real world it does. They may be better in the fantasy world but not in real life.

P4P is mythical, it's not real. Is there a belt for being a number 1 P4P? So in real life Manny beat number 3 rank P4P, while Floyd won via 2 judges and took away the only chance of Marcos winning the fight. 221 punches landed on Floyd, the most he took so far. Imagine if Marcos have his MX gloves on, he'll be walking like Broner after he fought Maidana going to his dressing room. Get real.

[salitap4p#1]

based on their last performance, yep i would put pac higher than floyd.

andre ward should really be at #1 but his inactivity prevents him from being so.

so pac's #1 for me for the time being.

[Toyman]

I already had manny back at #1 after he beat bradley because no matter how floyd beat maidana, it was just maidana who is basically brandon rios' twin.


floyd hasnt really had a significant win in a long time against a truly prime, established opponent. and due to this fact, i cant really justify having him #1. Manny easily has the most significant victory in the last year.

1. Manny
2. Floyd
3. Wlad
4. Bradley
5. JMM

[kurt0411]

I already had manny back at #1 after he beat bradley because no matter how floyd beat maidana, it was just maidana who is basically brandon rios' twin.


floyd hasnt really had a significant win in a long time against a truly prime, established opponent. and due to this fact, i cant really justify having him #1. Manny easily has the most significant victory in the last year.

1. Manny
2. Floyd
3. Wlad
4. Bradley
5. JMM

I completely agree with this, you can obviously twist floyd and manny around but one thing is for sure ward has to go, don't care how skilled he is.

[noStylez]

I already had manny back at #1 after he beat bradley because no matter how floyd beat maidana, it was just maidana who is basically brandon rios' twin.


floyd hasnt really had a significant win in a long time against a truly prime, established opponent. and due to this fact, i cant really justify having him #1. Manny easily has the most significant victory in the last year.

1. Manny
2. Floyd
3. Wlad
4. Bradley
5. JMM

Maidana is better than Rios but boy if both of them got in the ring it would be one hell of a fight.

[face untouched]

no way

1.Mayweather
2.Ward
3.Rigondeux
4.Garcia
5.Broner

[blacksocks]

It's okay Pacquiao lost to Marquez after beating him twice, but Floyd getting beat up by Maidana? Doesn't look like a top P4P'er to me.

[Pain~Lucy]

mayweather #1! ward should be 3 or 4