should pac be p4p # 1?

[Robbie Barrett]

u dont get it p4p ranking is base on skills

so u will have to imagine marquez is naturally the same size as canelo or canelo the same size with marquez

marquez will counter canelo all night

thats how p4p ranking is

You don't get it. We are going on the actual fights. In the real world size makes a difference. If Mayweather beats Rigondeaux would that be a good win because he's on the P4P list? No because he's too big.

[DoubleLeftH00k]

You don't get it. We are going on the actual fights. In the real world size makes a difference. If Mayweather beats Rigondeaux would that be a good win because he's on the P4P list? No because he's too big.

my thread is p4p rankings not actual fights
p4p is base on skillwise not size

base on ur mind wlad should be number one coz he'll step on floyd like an ant

u have to forget fighters size advantage and have a fantasy fight in mind

[Robbie Barrett]

my thread is p4p rankings not actual fights

base on ur mind wlad should be number one coz he'll step on floyd like an ant

We are discussing recent opponents of both Mayweather and Pacquiao. You said JMM and Bradley are better and would beat any of Mayweathers. I disagree because Canelo would beat both at 152. Which is the weight Mayweather fought him at, he didn't fight him at the mythical P4P weight class.

[Augustane]

It's now

1) Manny/Floyd
2) Wlad
3) Rigo
4) Ward
5) Bradley
6) Martinez/Marquez
7)

Or something in that line.

[Wenpire]

PAC is clearly #1. PAC beat a p4p #3 bradley while Fraud jr gets beat down by Maidana. Ward hasn't done jack sh!et and rigo should be number 2.

[DoubleLeftH00k]

We are discussing recent opponents of both Mayweather and Pacquiao. You said JMM and Bradley are better and would beat any of Mayweathers. I disagree because Canelo would beat both at 152. Which is the weight Mayweather fought him at, he didn't fight him at the mythical P4P weight class.

okay canelo beats both due to size advantage
now what?
does that mean floyd beating canelo is better than pac beating bradley?
heck no...

again my thread and discussion in p4p rankings
skillwise rankings

bradley beats canelo in p4p
marquez beats canelo in p4p

stick to the topic

[Robbie Barrett]

okay canelo beats both due to size advantage
now what?
does that mean floyd beating canelo is better than pac beating bradley?
heck no...

again my thread and discussion in p4p rankings
skillwise rankings

bradley beats canelo in p4p
marquez beats canelo in p4p

stick to the topic

Actually in the real world it does. They may be better in the fantasy world but not in real life.

[assiong]

Pacquiao will never be P4P #1 again.

Why is that? Please give us your intelligent response.

[Robbie Barrett]

Why is that? Please give us your intelligent response.

He's got nobody to fight. Who's he got at Top rank? JMM and Bradley beating them again doesn't move him to the top spot. Sorry.

[DoubleLeftH00k]

Actually in the real world it does. They may be better in the fantasy world but not in real life.

nope its not a better win in any way

floyd beaten a hype job in real world
while pac beaten a top dog in real world

check ur world ur living it might be fake