Sugar Shane's Resume is better than Floyd's and Pacquaio's

[hectari]

If losses count then journeymen and stepping stones/B fighters are much greater than some ATG's and HOF'ers.

DeMarcus Corley:

Mayweather
Cotto
Judah
Maidana
Matthysse
Provodnikov
Alexander
Witter
Bailey 2x
Dulorme
McCloskey
Postol
Aydin
Theopane

Glen Johnson:

Hopkins
Jones
Tarver 2x
Froch
Dawson
Groves
Bute
Cloud
Woods 2x
Gonzalez
Ulrich
Sosa
Vanderpool
Ottke

^End thread

[Larry the boss]

why do ya'll make such ****** threads? how do you count loses to anyones resume?

[MRCHOKEaMF]

Everytime someone brings up margarito as some beast remember shane utterly destroyed him

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Everytime someone brings up margarito as some beast remember shane utterly destroyed him

true, but i think it gets overlooked that the cotto fight took alot out of margs,, everyone talks about cotto gettting ruined in that fight but both i think got ruined in that fight

[BoxingGenius27]

Shane has one maybe 2 top level wins in his whole career.. Dont get me wrong, he fought an incredible list of great opponents but at the end of the day he beat oscar and he beat margs... Other than that he lost all his big fights vs top guys
Vargas, mayorga, were way past it by the time they fought shane

The Collazo win was pretty good. So were the two Vargas wins.

I thought Shane won the 2nd Wright fight.

[Rudiamonds]

Margarito a cheater joke take his plasters away he doesn't win a single fight.....he beat oscar on PEDs

[Sugar Adam Ali]

The Collazo win was pretty good. So were the two Vargas wins.

I thought Shane won the 2nd Wright fight.

Those are solid wins, but not enough to be better than floyd or manny

winky won the 2nd fight,, much closer than the first but a solid 115-113 win for winky IMO

Collazo win looks better and better as time passes...

Vargas was past it, but still a solid win for shane

[ElCaneloAlvarez]

Mosley has always been overrated, he had good speed and power but he was as stiff as a broomstick and had poor movement, and was always jittery and tentative.