Sugar Shane's Resume is better than Floyd's and Pacquaio's

[Flash13]

Sorry but no. No one embarasses a prime Oscar, he lost a controversial split, then got robbed in the rematch where he outboxed a PED inflated Mosley.

Get your facts straight.

I agree. I felt that while the first fight was close Shane deserves the nod. However, the second fight was clearly a robbery.

[Twako]

cotto-mosley WAS NOT a robbery. i had cotto edging shane, and i wanted shane to win. but if you had shane edging miguel, i wont complain. but it wasn't a clear cut shane win and def not a robbery.

[Saul_Good]

Nice names on the list, but like someone else already said, it's only validated with wins...

Hell, just look at Mayorga's resume.. some big names, but is he an ATG because of it?

[big_james10]

-Prime oscar x2- he embarrassed him.

-Prime Magarito- Floyd ducked, SSM obliterated him.
-Ricardo Mayorga-Ko
-Manny pacquaio- This alone brings SSM a whole another level from floyd
-Fought -prime Cotto- Robbery
-Prime -Saul alvarez
-Floyd mayweather - This alone brings SSM a whole another level from Pac-and ducked floyd
-Prime- Vernon Frost
-fought -Winky Wright
-fought-Fernando Vargas
-fought-Anthony Mundine

As you can see a sure Hall of Famer. His resume is level above both pac's and mayweather and is incredibly deep. There's no comparison.

Based on your twisted logic, if you fight great fighters or great fights and lose the majority of the time, that makes you a Hall of Famer. If that's the case, Emmanuel Augustus (look him up in Boxrec since you have no clue who he is) is a lock for the Boxing Hall of Fame after he retires.

As far as your list is concerned, Anthony Mundine was a journeyman who never defeated anyone of note and Mosley lost to him.

Fernando Vargas was exposed as a hype job when he was knocked out by both Felix Trinidad and ODLH after both moved up from 147 to fight him before Mosley fought him.

Winky Wright was a great fighter in his prime, and Mosley lost both fights to him.

Vernon Forest was a great fighter in his prime at 147 and Mosley lost both fights to him.

The Cotto fight was close (I scored it a draw) but Mosley lost to him

.
Mayorga was winning their fight on the scorecards when Mosley knocked him out with one second left in the fight.

The Margarito fight was definitely a huge victory for Mosley, especially since he was the underdog.

He didn't embarrass Oscar. Both fights with ODLH were close. I gave Mosley the first fight and Oscar the second one.

When he fought Pacquaio, he was past his prime. He would have beaten Pacquaio in his prime as evidenced by the fact that Freddie Roach said he was too good for Pacquaio after Mosley KO'd Margarito.

When he fought Alvarez , he was waaaaaay past his prime. If he had fought Alvarez in his prime, Mosley probably would have KO'd him.

As for Mayweather, nothing needs to be said about that fight, except that Mosley turned the fight down both at welterweight and at lightweight before they finally met.

If losing 9 out of 14 fights against quality fighters make you a great fighter, then Mosley should be considered the greatest of all time.

[Wizardsh]

Shane not ATG?. and you call yourself a fan?. GTFO hater.

Stfu why should a know cheater be called a atg or hof?

[JaguaresMx]

all the **** that Pac, Floyd, JMM and others who have never tested positive get, and Shane Mosley's certified PED use usually thrown under the rug.

[A-Wolf]

"Prime Margarito"

[thuggery]

[Richard Wadd]

robbed against cotto

shane's resume of quality wins is thin despite a great win over oscar. he did fight really good opposition, give him his props for that

[-Kev-]

If losses count then journeymen and stepping stones/B fighters are much greater than some ATG's and HOF'ers.

DeMarcus Corley:

Mayweather
Cotto
Judah
Maidana
Matthysse
Provodnikov
Alexander
Witter
Bailey 2x
Dulorme
McCloskey
Postol
Aydin
Theopane

Glen Johnson:

Hopkins
Jones
Tarver 2x
Froch
Dawson
Groves
Bute
Cloud
Woods 2x
Gonzalez
Ulrich
Sosa
Vanderpool
Ottke