How did you score the Garcia/Herrera fight?

[ßringer]

8-4 Herrera. It wasn't a hard fight to score. Most of the people that had it close are Philly natives and Islanders, can't really blame those guys, their boy got whipped.

I take umbrage with this post.

Yeah, I'm from Philly, but I loathe Danny Garcia (wanted Matthysse to murder him) , so there was no favoritism whatsoever in my scoring of the fight.

The fight was close in a Holyfield/Valuev sort of way. Meaning that both guys were content to do **** all to secure the victory and then everybody in NSB pissed and moaned about the outcome for weeks after it had ended.

This wasn't Whitaker/Chavez. This wasn't Casamayor/Santa Cruz. It was two 'tards acting like they were sparring instead of fighting for a world title.

[UTEP]

I take umbrage with this post.

Yeah, I'm from Philly, but I loathe Danny Garcia (wanted Matthysse to murder him) , so there was no favoritism whatsoever in my scoring of the fight.

The fight was close in a Holyfield/Valuev sort of way. Meaning that both guys were content to do **** all to secure the victory and then everybody in NSB pissed and moaned about the outcome for weeks after it had ended.

This wasn't Whitaker/Chavez. This wasn't Casamayor/Santa Cruz. It was two 'tards acting like they were sparring instead of fighting for a world title.

Damn you're from Philly? Didn't know that. To me it was a very easy fight to score. 8-4 Herrera. Same score these guys had.


Chris Davies (LCD Boxing) : 116-112 Herrera

John A MacDonald (Live Fight) : 116-112 Herrera

Steve Farhood (Showtime TV) : 116-112 Herrera

Michael Woods (The Sweet Science) : 116-112 Herrera

Bradley Edwards (Freelance) : 116-112 Herrera

The Boxing Expert : 116-112 Herrera

Steve Lillis (Boxnation TV) : 116-112 Herrera

Gabriel Montoya (Maxboxing) : 116-112 Herrera

Boxing.com : 116-112 Herrera




Hopefully Danny has the cajones to give Herrera a rematch, He owes it to him, the fans, and the media.

[Bigg Rigg]

6-6 Draw or 7-5 Win for Herrera.

[SlySlickSmooth]

Garcia, EASILY 11-1. I don't know how others scored even 3 let alone FOUR rounds for Herrera. Blind bastards.

[IronDanHamza]

8-4 Herrera. It wasn't a hard fight to score. Most of the people that had it close are Philly natives and Islanders, can't really blame those guys, their boy got whipped.

Not a hard fight to score? oh yeah because there were so many dominant rounds.

[UTEP]

Garcia, EASILY 11-1. I don't know how others scored even 3 let alone FOUR rounds for Herrera. Blind bastards.

.............

[cameltoe]

Same as above- a draw, or possibly 7-5 Herrera.

Many close rounds that could have been given either way.

No robbery.

[Larry the boss]

boring,close fight,could go either way

[John Locke]

8-4 Herrera.

[Dfan25]

115-113 Garcia