Comments Thread For: Garcia, Schaefer Say He Is No. 3 Pound-For-Pound

[Fetta]

what everybody was afraid of when GBP first purchased ring magazine is totally manifesting itself today and in recent years.

The unjust inclusion of Adrien freaking Broner, Canelo Alvarez, and freaking Robert Guerrero to top 10 p4p status for the sole purpose of propping up floyd and broner's resume and make the fight more appealing is downright shameful.

All those undeserving guys were made p4p top 10 because they were GBP fighters.

Now they continue to do it with Garcia.

DISGUSTING.

I actually think Garcia is a top 10

[DSGteamko]

Mayweather ain't a fighter... he's a BOXER. Pure boxing abuser at its best.

Do not offend boxing genius calling him a fighter.

Chocha Alvarez is a fighter, Triple Duck is a fighter, Chavez jr is a fighter.

you are right. mala mia. Best BOXER in the WORLD

[Cuban Linx]

I actually think Garcia is a top 10

So do I. He's earned it, unlike Guerrero, Broner and Canelo.

[bojangles1987]

Hold on so he arguably lost to Murray in your eyes, which i dont think, but you take into consideration that but not the fact that EVERYONE thinks Bradley lost to Pac.

But hey P4P is personal likes and dislikes so if thats how you have it then thats cool.

I 100% take into account that Pacquiao beat Bradley. Losing to Pacquiao but giving a game effort is a hundred times better than Sergio nearly losing to Martin Murray. And he beat Marquez since, who was top 4, while everyone else that belonged above him before was either inactive or losing. Bradley earned a top 4 spot.

[jbpanama]

My Opinion........
Not Many Cat's at, 40, 47. can Hang With Danny!!!

[LA_2_Vegas]

Must be fight week.

[MMegatron]

Mayweather #1
Ward #2 - Ward is not losing to anyone soon unless he moves up, even then maybe not.
Klitschko is #3. Outclassed everyone in his division for 10 years
Mikey Garcia #4.

Next 4 is between:

Martinez - still not lost but needs to impress to maintain as weak performances since injured.
Bradley - lucky gifted Pac win, if he wins rematch (really wins) he is there.
Marquez - lost to Bradley, but beat Pac.
Pac - KO'd and needs to prove hes back again even tho against his worst opponent, Bradley loss means nothing.

Then next 2 places between:

Rigo - only had 13 fights. Beat Santa Cruz and hes in the next group.
Froch - on his record, but needs a good performance in rematch vs Groves. If not hes out, even with a disputed win.
Garcia - good and has beaten some decent fighters but Khan and Mathysse aren't p4ps and Judah and Morales were old. Can he do it against Bradley, Marquez, Pac?
Kovalev / Stevenson - whoever wins is in the next group up
Canelo - needs another big win to consolidate place
GGG - Mainly based on Macklin's assessment and what i've seen. Needs to beat Martinez tho.

Eventually:

Anthony Joshua - this guy will clear out the heavyweight division in the next 5 years. Forget Fury, Wilder and all those loud mouth thugs.

so:
Mayweather
Ward
Klitschko
M Garcia
Pac
Bradley
Marquez
Martinez
Froch
Rigo

[lov 2 box]

And Lara lost to PWill, Abril lost to Rios etc yet nobody evrer makes a point of acknowledging the crooked decisions like your sorry alt a$$ just did

Stop crying lil bit**.... you seem to left out the 3 times Marquez was robbed against that pacfr##d

[RichCCFC]

lol...................boxing is dead when Garcia is #3 p4p

[icerob]

1)Mayweather
2)Ward
3)Rigo
4)Bradley
5)Klitschko
6)Pacquiao
7)Marquez
8)Garcia D
9)Garcia M
10)GGG

You have GGG in your top 10 and no Sergio? LOL! Im GGG fan too but i know better than to put him in top 10 at this point.