Whose win over Soto Karass was more impressive, Keith Thurman or Marcos Maidana?

[BUNGALOWS]

No, an even fight is a draw, ex: 65-65, 68-68.


You said i didn't understand basic scoring so i called you a *** face no hard feelings.

[fundicao]

Thurman

For maidana it was just a tune up

[daggum]

All the judges had Maidana up at the time of the stoppage. 65-64, 66-63, 65-64

thank you mr. literal. now if we want to see an even fight we need to watch floyd-canelo because one judge scored it a draw.

[Grimgash]

Saying a fight was even means a close back and forth fight, saying it is a draw up to that point means ....it was a draw....but semantics I guess.

[UTEP]

[UTEP]

Saying a fight was even means a close back and forth fight, saying it is a draw up to that point means ....it was a draw....but semantics I guess.

1 point means everything in this sport, it's the difference between a draw and a close fight.

[daggum]

1 point means everything in this sport, it's the difference between a draw and a close fight.

yeah and scoring is subjective. the official judges had maidana up well woopty-do! do you trust those cheats? i remembered it was a razor close fight and either guy could have been up at the time of the early stoppage. of course maidana was officially up. he's the a-side. whether he deserved to be is another question and i'd have to watch the fight again except i don't have time to do that. i have to bash vitali some more.

[Weebler I]

Thurman's win was more comprehensive. Thurman v Maidana is a great fight if MM continues to fight after the FMJ bout.

[John Locke]

Thurman won every round and actually put Karass to sleep. Luckily the ref caught him before he hit the canvas.

Maidana won via TKO in a far more competitive fight.

[UTEP]

yeah and scoring is subjective. the official judges had maidana up well woopty-do! do you trust those cheats? i remembered it was a razor close fight and either guy could have been up at the time of the early stoppage. of course maidana was officially up. he's the a-side. whether he deserved to be is another question and i'd have to watch the fight again except i don't have time to do that. i have to bash vitali some more.

Hell no, i trust my own eyes. I had Maidana up 4 rounds to 3 going into the 8th, give it a look when you get a chance.