Should Mayweather have 2 losses on his record?

[Jack Napier]

Floyd's only loss is the 1st Castillo fight

[makinchedder]

Floyd's only loss is the 1st Castillo fight

its a W in the history books..... lmfao

[The Big Dunn]

First off the decision he got against Castillo which in a lot of peoples mind was a unfair decision which Mayweather got due to the fact he was probably seen as the prospect and the guy who now is gathering the masses and bring a lot of attention into boxing.

In his first fight with Castillo he (Floyd) was out-hustled, he wasn't landing enough shots to steal rounds and the fact that Castillo was the lightweight champion and he was fighting more like the challenger who wanted it more It kind of makes you wonder.

We've seen this happen with other previous fighters who have been hand-fed the same silver spoon treatment Mayweather had and getting the benefit of the doubt AKA Adrien Broner, albeit Broner is not anywhere near the level Mayweather is and Maywether is a genuinely very talented fighter.
Broner has had several fights (Quintero, PDL, Malinaggi) people had him losing but he managed to pull off a decision.


Right that was just the first loss I was talking about the second one comes in at when Mayweather fought Zab Judah...



00:15 seconds into the fight Mayweather gets a nice shot to his nuts and Roger Mayweather steps into the ring and at that point the fight by the rules SHOULD of been a DQ thus resulting in a victory for Zab.



Skip to 10:50
When James Kirkland fought Carlos Molina, Kirkland knocks Molina down in the 10th round and Molinas corner come into the ring and the fight is called off as a DQ and Kirkland is the winner.

What is the difference between that and what Roger did?
Roger did considerably worse as he needed police to take him out of the ring, I think my opinion its a biased agenda to protect Mayweathers 0 as they realized they need this cash cow to milk every last penny they can get from him because once Mayweather is gone who else is there?


You may now commence with hating on me

You were better when you were keitha313.

[makinchedder]

You were better when you were keitha313.

why give any attention.... these floyd haters think about him far more then his fans lmfao.

[Curtiz]

Sad you'd put quotations of things you said in your own sig

You are from glasgow = typical scumbag

Zangief.....growup son.

/End

[Kuyukut]

I watch the fight I gave Floyd 4 rounds but I can't argue with ****** as you will never comprehend so your a waste of time

same here i gave floyd 4 rounds.

[BIGBOXINGFAN]

8-4
Floyd won hands down

[mezoomozaa]

I haven't watched all Mayweather fights, specially the old ones, because I don't like his style, and I don't like the fact that he is American !
but from what I have watched for him, I honestly think he lost twice, the first was with Castillo , who dominated him in the first fight, and put a good show in the second and lost a close decision !

and the second loss was with Canelo Alvarez ! this Mexican green boxer grew big in me after his last fight with Mayweather, he put a very good effort, I had him winning UD, and I am still trying to understand how Mayweather won " every single round " of this fight in the eyes of some posters here !

I respect their opinion, but Mayweather can't win " every single round " with any boxer, he always starts slow, trying to adapt, then steals the later rounds with clear 2-3 punches !

May be I am not fair, because I don't like the persona of " Money ", I respect people of values more !

Mayweather will not be remembered in the history of boxing, even his PPVs records will be broken very easily by any near future superstar !

People like Ali, Tyson or SRL would make the double or triple of Mayweather numbers easily if they were fighting today !