Floyd vs Maidana a bigger mismatch that Floyd vs Guerrero?

[DJR005]

I am a fan of Maidana. I love a fighter w Heart, KO power, and someone who always swinging. But let's be honest Marcos has no speed and to give Floyd a good fight you must have speed, great skill and ring intelligence. I just don't think Marcos has any of those. He does keep coming no matter what tho and that's a big plus for him. I just don't see someone with no speed getting past Floyd's defense.

[Queen_Leia]

I am a fan of Maidana. I love a fighter w Heart, KO power, and someone who always swinging. But let's be honest Marcos has no speed and to give Floyd a good fight you must have speed, great skill and ring intelligence. I just don't think Marcos has any of those. He does keep coming no matter what tho and that's a big plus for him. I just don't see someone with no speed getting past Floyd's defense.

You are right but Floyd had to fight somebody....gotta get paid.

[bigsmoothh]

i dont think so, this is boxing and sooner or later that 0 has got to go.

[285Kid]

Mayweather's greatest threats (Tim Bradley, Manny Pacquiao Sergio Martinez and Gennady Golovkin) are not in the mix by their mere association with either Top Rank or HBO so its doesn't matter anymore who he fights

[KingTito]

No, and a lot of that is because of Maidana's power. Maidana is relentless in his pressure as well.

[DJR005]

Mayweather's greatest threats (Tim Bradley, Manny Pacquiao Sergio Martinez and Gennady Golovkin) are not in the mix by their mere association with either Top Rank or HBO so its doesn't matter anymore who he fights

Very good point

[FrankieClutch]

no. At least if Maidana lands something there's a chance he can hurt Floyd. There was literally nothing that Guerrero could do to Mayweather to trouble him

[turkas]

I don't think so at all. Personally I was never really that impressed with Robert above 135 and he was over rated at ww. I never gave Robert a chance at all, at least with Maidana he has undeniable power that equalize things.

[fish262]

Mayweather's greatest threats (Tim Bradley, Manny Pacquiao Sergio Martinez and Gennady Golovkin) are not in the mix by their mere association with either Top Rank or HBO so its doesn't matter anymore who he fights

Lara and Kirkland should be in the mix as well.

[-PBP-]

Yes. I picked Guerrero to beat Maidana when that fight was scheduled and I stand by that pick today.