Who is More Overrated, Canelo or Broner?

[White_Knight]

It's amazing to me that Canelo is "overrated" when he and Lara have the same top win, but Lara is now seen as this monster (yet struggled vs friggen Vanes and Molina)

Most fans scored the Canelo vs Trout fight for Trout. There is no possible way a fans could have scored Lara vs Trout for Trout. Also, Lara beat Williams who Floyd avoided by taking a 2-year holiday.

[Holywarrior]

Most fans scored the Canelo vs Trout fight for Trout. There is no possible way a fans could have scored Lara vs Trout for Trout. Also, Lara beat Williams who Floyd avoided by taking a 2-year holiday.

Come on? Where is your source for this?

[dynomyte1444]

how the fcuk is canelo overrated. Damn these threads get more dumb by the day

[White_Knight]

Come on? Where is your source for this?

TOTAL: 194 SCORES.......TROUT 106..........CANELO 81........DRAW 7


PRESS: 45 SCORES...........TROUT 19............CANELO 23........DRAW 3


FANS: 149 SCORES...........TROUT 87............CANELO 58........DRAW 4

http://fightscorecollector.blogspot....q=canelo+trout

These scores were taken just after the Canelo-Trout fight, so it can't be argued that people scored the fight for Trout to try to discredit Floyd, who hadn't announced Canelo as an opponent yet.

[toshmurph]

Canelo has to be the more overrated,,,, both are hype jobs, but canelo is getting put into a ppv main event after getting undressed by floyd

Neither has impressed me much in terms of being the next major superstar,, Fernando Vargas was a much better prospect than canelo

Broner hasnt headlined any ppv yet, let alone headlining one after an embarrassing loss

Canelo has the most hype of any up coming fighter, so it has to be Canelo

What bull**** are you talking? The reason Canelo is a PPV headliner is because the kid is a massive draw! You don't need to be over rated or under rated to be a PPV draw!

Arturo Gatti was an average fighter all his life, but was a huge draw from an early age due to his style and exciting fights! Now I don't think anybody would have ever called him a p4p worthy fighter!

An Irish guy John Duddy, was big in the USA a few years ago due to the large irish contingent in America! He was never overrated, the guy was a walking punching bag that had a cinder block chin!

News flash Canelo is fighting a fellow Mexican who is also a big draw, and the fight is PPV because it will sell well with the huge Latino market and some casual fans! It's called business sense and doesn't impact how each fighters ability is perceived!!

Oh and btw why are you bringing up Feroz? The guy retired years ago, this is a discussion about Broner and Alvarez!

[Holywarrior]

TOTAL: 194 SCORES.......TROUT 106..........CANELO 81........DRAW 7


PRESS: 45 SCORES...........TROUT 19............CANELO 23........DRAW 3


FANS: 149 SCORES...........TROUT 87............CANELO 58........DRAW 4

http://fightscorecollector.blogspot....q=canelo+trout

These scores were taken just after the Canelo-Trout fight, so it can't be argued that people scored the fight for Trout to try to discredit Floyd, who hadn't announced Canelo as an opponent yet.

Oh no, the fight score collector? Really? The guy gets the meat of his scores from websites. I see his posts all the time and I just laugh.

Thanks for the media scorecards though

[Jcsuper]

broner by a thousand miles

[wave]

Canelo...he's practically never fought anybody his own size

[Sugar Adam Ali]

What bull**** are you talking? The reason Canelo is a PPV headliner is because the kid is a massive draw! You don't need to be over rated or under rated to be a PPV draw!

Arturo Gatti was an average fighter all his life, but was a huge draw from an early age due to his style and exciting fights! Now I don't think anybody would have ever called him a p4p worthy fighter!

An Irish guy John Duddy, was big in the USA a few years ago due to the large irish contingent in America! He was never overrated, the guy was a walking punching bag that had a cinder block chin!

News flash Canelo is fighting a fellow Mexican who is also a big draw, and the fight is PPV because it will sell well with the huge Latino market and some casual fans! It's called business sense and doesn't impact how each fighters ability is perceived!!

Oh and btw why are you bringing up Feroz? The guy retired years ago, this is a discussion about Broner and Alvarez!

True he is a big draw,, but his team and handlers and media act like he was the next greatest thing to come to boxing.. He literally has not showed anything except for being a decent fighter.. He is no way the next oscar, or even Mexican legend.. Gatti was never a big PPv attraction, especially after he would get whooped, he didn't immediately comeback on PPv...

Canelo has to have more hype than broner... Both have accomplished very little, neither had a hot streak of fights, but broner was considered a "future" star, whereas canelo is thought of as a current superstar...

I only mention Vargas because he was a young champ at 20 like canelo, and destroyed guys, whereas canelo has not looked dominant vs hatton, trout, Rhodes, old mosely.. I just don't see how canelo has earned this popularity or hype..

[J-champ]

Both are overrated some but Canelo passed the better tests.