Comments Thread For: Garcia: Maidana Earned Mayweather With Broner Win

[PunchyPotorff]

Look at one example... ESPN's Maidana vs Khan poll. 2/3 voted Maidana, 1/3 voted Khan. Just THAT poll alone proves the Floydie poll is fake.

[jagzsj]

Quote:

Originally Posted by jrrod02 n

He's right.
If the choice is Maidana or Khan, the clear choice should be Maidana.

I agree. Obviously at ww-tim, jmm, and manny, are ranked ahead of Maidana. Tim and Manny are better ww opponents. Expanding to 154, Lara would be better than Maidan IMO.

So i think he is the 4th best option overall and the 2nd best of whose available.

Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

[hugh grant]

Why does specifically beating broner earn you a shot at Floyd? What is it aboiut Broner? Why doesn't beating Maidana and Paul Malignaggi earn you a shot at Floyd like Khan did?

OK, Khan beat them a few years ago, so Floyd should have fought khan years ago then.

[shenmue]

Despite what you may think about Malignaggi, he's a savvy, skilled fighter with a great chin and a lot of heart. His biggest weakness is he doesn't hit hard, due in no small part to his hands giving him problems early in his career. Yet, he's 33-5. Broner's split decision win over him was an eye opener that suggested Adrien might not have brought his power to WW. It doesn't make Paulie an unworthy opponent. Broner was 26-0 before facing Maidana, with 22KOs, so he's not a slouch. Alexander has 2 losses in 27 fights, both coming at the hands of undefeated fighters Bradley and Porter. So he's not exactly a slouch either. Maidana only has 3 losses in 38 fights, with an 81.58% KO record and a belt. Paper champion? Hardly. http://boxrec.com/list_bouts.php?hum...7790&cat=boxer

No point talking to hitking, he said Broner would dominate Maidana but now that Maidana dominated Broner that win means very little to him which makes no sense. He is Maidana hater which is a shame but its true.